News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sports Bars and Biker Gangs – The Death of Reddit by 78666cdc on Sunday July 12, 2015 @05:11PM (#9874984)
While I agree with everything you said after the quote you cited, I disagree with the suggestion that there are really any accurate observations in this article.

The entire "sports bar and biker gang" premise is entirely flawed. The picture painted is that of some perfect place which gets bastardized and taken over by some unsavory group of people who are unsavory even if only because of their memborship in said group.

How does it make any sense to allegorize such a gigantic online community as "a good place that got stormed by shitty users"? Yes, there are definitely Reddit users that get off on spending their free time harassing others. However, they are not many, and, for every handful there are, there are 100x more content creators, blog authors submitting content, people campaigning for charities, and so on.

If the presence of a few foul people are enough to make you vacate an entire massive community and feel as though you cannot participate, then I might suggest that you grow up a bit, learn that there is literally no public place in the world that is all rainbows and puppies, and check whether you are being overly sensitive.

Aside from that, the author's view on how any of this works is obviously and completely incorrect. The suggestion of "taking what's there" and "moving it somewhere else where the bad people won't go" belies the incredibly and simplistic worldview behind this article - you cannot pick and and move a community of people to another place, you cannot raise a big banner that says "I don't like it here!" and bring all of your well-established users to another place. Your users do not take such a (frankly, whiny) take on the world. They appreciate the platform, what's been there, and so on.

As for bemoaning why the biggest subreddits aren't controlled by the admin? In the end this is perhaps the single defining comment in this article. "Why, oh why don't the admins exert draconion control over their users so that I don't have to hear and come across things I disagree with?!" Because that's not how communities work, because that's not how open discussion works, because that's now how any of this works at all.

Frankly, I find the author's mindset absolutely infuriating. Why is this incredibly naive, oversensitive, and whiny post getting any attention at all? Anyone that has been around online communities (and, frankly, life after college) for longer than a year can easily recognize this sort of bullshit.

Edit: To pre-empt some responses, no, I am not standing up and saying that harassing users should be left alone because of freedom of speech. There is obviously a limit - active and purposeful harm should be prevented as much as reasonably possible if one wants to maintain a large community with a positive public image. However, the "biker gang moving into my space" analogy is exactly the sort of analogy I would expect from the sort of person that is ready to cry victim at the slightest provocation - and those sorts of people, in fact, are exactly the ones that have had the most damage on online communities in the past few years.

Furthermore, am I the only one so far to comment on the fact that the "biker gang" image the author evokes is inherently judgmental and simple-minded? The hypocrisy in just that one analogy is astounding. Shame on this author and his/her cognitive dissonance, victim complex, and naivety.

Re:Sports Bars and Biker Gangs – The Death of Reddit by KVFinn on Sunday July 12, 2015 @05:21PM (#9875018)
>If the presence of a few foul people are enough to make you vacate an entire massive community and feel as though you cannot participate, then I might suggest that you grow up a bit, learn that there is literally no public place in the world that is all rainbows and puppies, and check whether you are being overly sensitive.

Some of the best communities (/AskHistorians and /AskScience) are already struggling with this. A mod from /AskHistorians:

https://np.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/3cxedn/i_am_steve_huff...

>To illustrate, without in any way intending to boast, it is clear that a number of current and past staff members at Reddit really enjoy AskHistorians. This has been made publicly clear a number of times. But the reality of Reddit is that AskHistorians was created by going against the grain, by struggling against Reddit's mechanisms rather than being organically created by them, and by quite frankly disregarding a number of statements about Reddit's underlying philosophy made by admins and CEOs alike. That mostly involves deleting an enormous quantity of comments, with the express purpose that they are not seen any more, that they are vanished into the aether.

>In addition, reddit's increasingly poor reputation on the internet might, for some people, be because of what they perceive as censorship. But in my experience, the majority of that poor reputation is garnered from the kind of communities that Reddit harbours, which have grown larger and increasingly restive. And so long as they're there and doing their thing we have to share a website with them. We have to share a website with communities that have racist slurs in their name, that spew raw bigotry like it's water for all the farms of China. A lot of our flaired users on AskHistorians are professionals in their fields, and at times it is pretty hard to keep convincing them to stay on a website like this. Most of that convincing consists of how much stuff we are able to keep out of our community. I don't see how that is remotely tenable if we're no longer able to actually leave seas of [deleted]

Re:Sports Bars and Biker Gangs – The Death of Reddit by 78666cdc on Sunday July 12, 2015 @05:32PM (#9875055)
Half the comments you cite are more about moderation tools than about users. As for the rest (specifically, the second one), I don't think that any reasonable person would confuse /r/CoonTown with /r/AskHistorians.
Re:Sports Bars and Biker Gangs – The Death of Reddit by KVFinn on Sunday July 12, 2015 @05:40PM (#9875093)
I cited only one comment, specifically this part:

>A lot of our flaired users on AskHistorians are professionals in their fields, and at times it is pretty hard to keep convincing them to stay on a website like this.

Re:Sports Bars and Biker Gangs – The Death of Reddit by 78666cdc on Sunday July 12, 2015 @05:51PM (#9875125)
I meant "half of the statements", not "half of the comments". That was very obvious from what I said, so I suspect that you are being intellectually dishonest.

Regardless, to stay on topic, out of "a lot" of people, then "at times" some will want to leave. Expecting a 100% retention rate all the time is unrealistic.

Maybe a few of them saw comments about atheism in /r/atheism, a very major subreddit, and weren't comfortable posting in a place that isn't a "safe space" for Christians? Maybe, maybe not - who knows? But if you want to define what's "safe" to allow in open discussion, then you're pointing your community towards the metaphorical grave. Whether there's a possibility of afterlife for a doomed community is an open question.

Re:Sports Bars and Biker Gangs – The Death of Reddit by jschwartzi on Sunday July 12, 2015 @05:22PM (#9875022)
I think the biker gang label is appropriate. I mean, any time you have a small group in a community who will show up and destroy or dominate the entire conversation about their negative behavior, how is that different from 15 guys in leather showing up and beating you senseless for suggesting that they go deal meth elsewhere? And if you see that happen repeatedly at a bar you frequent, would you continue drinking there?
Re:Sports Bars and Biker Gangs – The Death of Reddit by 78666cdc on Sunday July 12, 2015 @05:29PM (#9875047)
You've missed the point that using the analogy of "biker gang" is inherently portraying groups of people that ride on motorcycles and have a favorite bar are inherently bad people. Biker gangs have often been portrayed in the media in a very stereotypical manner that has little bases in reality. How would it sound if I used the analogy of a "gang of black thugs with their baggy pants and shitty music" moved into my community and ruined it, and that "they should get high and make our white women uncomfortable elsewhere"? Same thing.

Look at your own comment of "go deal meth elsewhere." Is the irony lost on you?

Even past that, the analogy is flawed because it assumes an organized group of "bad people" that move into "my space". There is no such organized group, and it is no one person's space.

Even past that, there is no group of people on Reddit that "show up and destroy or dominate the entire conversation." I've been on Reddit actively for about seven years and while I definitely see the vitriolic individuals (and some specific toxic subreddits), I think it is incredibly childish to suggest that "my safe space is ruined by all these bad people!" The site has not been "dominated" by "the bad people". It feels ridiculous to have to say that about a place that gets, what, 7+ billion pageviews a month now?

Come on.

Re:Sports Bars and Biker Gangs – The Death of Reddit by jschwartzi on Sunday July 12, 2015 @07:35PM (#9875459)
Well, that's a good point. You're right about the use of Biker Gang as a pejorative being in the same vein as your statement. I still think that I agree with the point that he's making that in a community which is inclusive enough you'll find people there who are openly hostile, and that you have to choose whether you accept the hostile people or the people they're hostile to. Depending on your choice you might then end up on the wrong side of history, irrespective of your original goals.
Re:Sports Bars and Biker Gangs – The Death of Reddit by banachtarski on Sunday July 12, 2015 @05:17PM (#9875005)
Exactly. The op doesn't understand reddit.

I read a lot of specific reddits (sub-communities) like /r/programming, /r/cpp, /r/math, etc. Honestly? I'm completely unaffected by the "biker gangs" he's rambling about.