Re:New York Times' Reddit Piece Shows Dangers of Internet Jo...
by tptacek on Saturday July 11, 2015 @03:14PM
(#9871153)
Your best argument that the Times has "flip-flopped" is that they couldn't make up their minds between calling Silicon Valley "sexist" or "male-dominated"?
I don't find that argument credible.
That doesn't mean I'm right, but it does mean that this is not a profitable line of argument for us. I'll go ahead and assert that both of those constructions mean the same thing.
>The Pao NYT piece never changes the directionality of the concerns it raises.
With respect to this particular piece, I was pointing out later revisions that do change the directionality of a particular concept, namely its description of silicon valley.
"Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief" becomes "Silicon Valley 2, Ellen Pao 0".
"the entrenched sexist culture of Silicon Valley" becomes
"the entrenched male-dominated culture of Silicon Valley" becomes
"the entrenched sexist culture of Silicon Valley" becomes
"the entrenched male-dominated culture of Silicon Valley".
That is not just a fleshing out of a narrative, but an editorial flip-flop. Sexist is a particular and egregious charge to lay on an entire culture - an editorial statement. Male-dominated is a fact, separable from the concept of sexist. One can be proven, one cannot. Subjective vs objective. Opinion vs journalism.