The personal attacks and name calling, which haven't been linked in your comments, were a bit much. However they were few and far in between.
No they were not. https://www.reddit.com/r/all was dominated by them for days following the banning of /r/FatPeopleHate.
Ellen Pao wasn't awful, but all-in-all, it's probably a good thing she stepped down. Hopefully, next time there's a huge community changeover or staff change in reddit, everyone will talk through it and about it reasonably, and everyone will be able to bat away the easily-led and the gleeful and/or bored shit-stirrers.
* Their comments were funny / reasonable / etc.; there was nothing wrong with them. GP was wrong to find it disgusting.
* Their comments were bad, but there's nothing we can do about them. Our society involves it being socially acceptable to tell jokes about how people should die because of their inability to articulate clear moderation policies on a popular website, and that's unfortunate, but there's no way that we'll be able to change that social norm. (Or, alternatively, changing that social norm carries unavoidable downsides.)
* Their comments were bad, it's possible to make it no longer socially acceptable to make those jokes, and it should happen.
This doesn't really have anything to do with how seriously we take them.
I believe in the power of speech. I believe that there is utility in being able to convey my thoughts, without someone else filtering or censoring them, to others. I believe that my words mean things, that they reflect what I believe. I believe that being a person "of your word" is an important thing: that when you say you will do something, you intend to do it. I believe that lies are, of themselves, clearly of negative moral value. (Which is not to express an opinion on whether lies can serve some greater moral good, just to say that they have inherent demerit.) I believe that if I care about my friends, I care about what they say; if I value my friends, I value what they say; if I respect my friends, I respect what they say.
It is out of that conviction that I think that restrictions on one's ability to speak, whether from a government or a private party, carry great power, which, like all power, can be abused.
If I don't assign a moral value to these coworkers' comments, if I don't care what they say, if I don't care to have opinions on their speech lest I risk "thought policing" them, if I believe that people may say bad things while intending to be good (or vice versa) and that's just okay... it seems that I have completely devalued the power of speech, and I have destroyed the very reason we care about free speech, without censoring a single word. If anyone can say anything and it could mean anything or nothing, and nobody cares, what is the point of speech?
They are not the average Reddit user.
Probably a huge majority of Reddit users have no idea who Ellen Pao is.
If the default home page and /r/all can all be flooded with posts about her, it's not exactly a small group of extremists.
If the default home page and /r/all can all
be flooded with posts about her, it's not
exactly a small group of extremists.
I don't think the numbers support that statement at all.Reddit has roughly 1.5 million daily users. Source: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/about/traffic
It only takes about a thousand (net) upvotes to get something to the front page.
So a very small (less than 1%) portion of the visitors can very much get things like "fire Ellen" posts onto the front page, especially when there's no opposing block of voters.
(In other words, there were no passionate defenders of Pao who were eagerly downvoting the posts that trashed her. There were only anti-Pao zealots, and a much larger userbase that simply didn't care much at all. Count me in the latter, FWIW.)
This is true of all forms of fundamentalism, off-line or on. and in all cases despite being the minority opinion it generally makes the entire environment they touch suck.
Now, I think one could make the argument that /r/Jokes should be more heavily moderated because it's a default sub, and should cater to a more vanilla, easily offended audience.
What about the subreddit comparing Ellen Pao to Pyongyang [0].
Jokes about Pao with over a +4000 positive score [1] [2] Jokes comparing Ellen Pao to Hitler. [3] I remember a post to /r/pics or /r/funny of Hitler's Wikipedia page, with Pao's photo instead of Hitler.
I ran into some old coworkers (who take Reddit WAAAY too seriously) at a bar during the weekend this whole thing was first blowing up. They were literally talking about how Pao needs to die. Then they got drunk, forgot they had ranted about her, and told me again how she needed to die.
This whole thing was really disgusting and made me hate the average Reddit user. I'll still browse some of the smaller subs, but I won't be touching the frontpage ever again.
[0] http://www.reddit.com/r/paoyongyang
[1] http://www.reddit.com/r/Jokes/comments/3c03y8/ellen_paos_car...
[2] http://www.reddit.com/r/Jokes/comments/3c05wq/what_sound_doe...
[3] http://www.reddit.com/r/Jokes/comments/3c0b5p/whats_the_diff...