News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is there a simple algorithm for intelligence? by dragonwriter on Friday July 10, 2015 @05:21PM (#9866773)
> If you forget your fear of "soul" and other terms not ratified by science journals, you'll find out there are plenty of theories in metaphysics and spirituality on what it means to be and what awareness is. It requires you to at the very least read those philosophical/theological concepts instead of dismissing it as "woo".

I've read them. They are, from a scientific point-of-view, all woo. Almost by definition. They necessarily appeal -- if they can be epistemologically justified at all -- to a non-utilitarian epistemology. Science is based on a radically utilitarian epistemology: claims are justified to the extent that they are demonstrably useful in explaining and predicting observed phenomena. Theories -- in the non-scientific sense, obviously -- that involve entities that produce results in the physical universe but which are not governed by physical law or controlled by physical events as they are conjectured to be outside of the physical universe -- are non-utilitarian. They are irrelevant to any predictive model of observed behavior, and it is impossible to distinguish by observation between the existence of such non-physical, uncaused causes and processes that are purely physical. Either (a) there exists an adequate scientific model of the process, in which case the model being an accurate model of an underlying physical process is indistinguishable from the uncaused cause merely mimicking the behavior of the model at the times it has been observed, or (b) there exists no adequate scientific model, in which case the physical process not yet being discovered is indistinguishable from a non-physical cause.

That's not to say that such conjectures cannot be true, just that they can never be validated or distinguished from either known or unknown physical processes.

Say we create a machine that behaves like a human to all outward measures. There is no way to distinguish between:

(1) Human and machine alike being purely physical,

(2) Humans having metaphysical features like a "soul" and internal awareness and machine simply mimicking behavior,

(3) Humans and machines alike having metaphysical features like a "soul" (perhaps because God chose to reward human ingenuity by creating a "soul" for the machine.)

Re:Is there a simple algorithm for intelligence? by eli_gottlieb on Friday July 10, 2015 @07:53PM (#9867742)
I think you meant "Pragmatist" epistemology, rather than "utilitarian", which is a moral theory.
Re:Is there a simple algorithm for intelligence? by dragonwriter on Friday July 10, 2015 @08:07PM (#9867805)
Since the context wasn't moral theory, the special definition of "utilitarian" has in the context of moral philosophy wasn't intended; "utilitarian" has a general sense outside of that context which is what was intended.

I avoided "Pragmatist" specifically because I'm familiar enough to know it refers to a philosophical school of thought that touches on the epistemological questions I was referring to, but not quite certain that the exact position I was referring to was within its scope (I knew it was along the same general lines.)