News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is there a simple algorithm for intelligence? by habitue on Friday July 10, 2015 @10:50AM (#9864232)
Let's say, for the sake of argument, that intelligence requires quantum effects to work. I don't see how going back to vitalist arguments will aid us in any way. Researching the phenomena, following evidence, making inferences from that evidence... that's how progress on that subject would be made. Not by going back to arguments made by people with less information than we have now.

Specifically, if we follow the evidence, and find that somehow, beyond all odds, the vitalists were correct (once you add "quantumness!" to the mix), then it's clearly only by lucky guess they were right. It would be something we could look back at and say "wow, that's an interesting coincidence" rather than "wow, those vitalists had it right all along, we should have paid closer attention".

Re:Is there a simple algorithm for intelligence? by JoeAltmaier on Friday July 10, 2015 @10:56AM (#9864271)
Its often by intuition that we know where to look. Lets not be arrogant and claim "ok, you guessed it right, but its only true if I measure it and prove its true". That's correct but disingenuous.
Re:Is there a simple algorithm for intelligence? by dragonwriter on Friday July 10, 2015 @11:08AM (#9864356)
Intuition can be correct, and it can be wildly wrong.

Science is how we separate the correct, the mildly wrong, and the wildly wrong intuitions.

Its not an alternative to intuition -- intuition is where hypotheses come from. (OTOH, vitalism isn't a hypothesis, simply an intuition that some aspects of living things are outside the domain of science. Its not testable -- if correct, its completely indistinguishable from some of the relevant aspects of living things simply not being sufficiently well modeled by the current state of science at any given time. So, its an intuition that is neither confirmable nor useful in any way.)

Re:Is there a simple algorithm for intelligence? by habitue on Friday July 10, 2015 @11:05AM (#9864334)
That's what I meant by rational inference, but if we look at it from the point of view of intuition, I'm saying our intuitions will be better because we have much better information now. We have no particular reason to weight heavily the intuitions of the vitalists in our search.
Re:Is there a simple algorithm for intelligence? by gnaritas on Friday July 10, 2015 @11:40AM (#9864559)
That's still simply luck; unfounded intuition is meaningless as it's wrong more often than not. That's it's occasionally correct is coincidence.
Re:Is there a simple algorithm for intelligence? by JoeAltmaier on Friday July 10, 2015 @11:47AM (#9864599)
I guess all scientific progress has been by coincidence then? That's what I mean by disingenuous; some credit has to be given to those that are right. There are an infinite number of wrong intuitions.
Re:Is there a simple algorithm for intelligence? by dragonwriter on Friday July 10, 2015 @11:57AM (#9864686)
> I guess all scientific progress has been by coincidence then?

Correct hypotheses are, in a sense, a product of fortune, and scientific progress requires them to happen sometimes, so, in a sense, that's true. Without a certain minimal degree of luck, you would have no scientific progress.

The scientific method can be viewed as simply a method of filtering out the intuitions without utility and promoting those (if any) that have utility. It is a way to avoid wasting the good fortune of the intuition of forming useful hypothesis, and avoiding the waste demonstrably fruitless intuitions.

> some credit has to be given to those that are right

But vitalism is so vague as to be untestable, and justifies no useful models. "Some (unspecified elements of) living things are not governed by physical law" is indistinguishable in effect from "We have not yet discovered the physical laws governing (some elements of) living things".

Re:Is there a simple algorithm for intelligence? by habitue on Monday July 13, 2015 @03:25PM (#9880414)
> Without a certain minimal degree of luck, you would have no scientific progress.

A minor disagreement on this point. I think often our intuitions are shaped by experience, and lead us to conclusions that we don't have a rational line of inference to (at least one we can explain). Science acts as a good filter, saying "we don't care how you came up with it, test it and we'll agree if it turns out it's right". This isn't a random guess, but it's far from reasoning you could convince anyone else with. This is different from a lucky guess. Your brain has been seeing a lot of the data, and is picking up on patterns, in other words your intuition is correlated with the phenomena, and that's what leads you to the theory you want to test.

Second, sometimes purely rational arguments lead us to theories from other data. This isn't random chance, but it is exploiting regularities in the world around us to predict new things. For example, kepler's laws of motion weren't the direct result of observation. You can't observe equations that guide the motion of the planets. In between observations, the planets might have jumped all over the place. But it was assumed that the planets weren't doing that, and simple equations were inferred from the data available that fit the evidence. There is a step here between "observation" and "prediction" that doesn't involve a lucky guess.

Re:Is there a simple algorithm for intelligence? by gnaritas on Friday July 10, 2015 @11:52AM (#9864633)
No, scientific progress comes from empirically chasing down and disproving false intuitions so that only the few true ones remain. Intuition creates hypothesis, empiricism makes them useful since nearly all intuitions are wrong. It's the empiricists that deserve the credit, they are why science works and of course are generally the ones with the intuitions that are correct as well.

And you can't say vitalists were right, they've made no predictions: calling something magic woo woo isn't a hypothesis that can be proven right.

Re:Is there a simple algorithm for intelligence? by JoeAltmaier on Friday July 10, 2015 @02:53PM (#9865972)
Which begs the question: where did the correct intuitions come from? Can't be random; there are billions of wrong ideas and only 1 right one. So some weight has to be given to intuitions, and some props to those who had the right ones. Because that's how progress gets made.
Re:Is there a simple algorithm for intelligence? by gnaritas on Friday July 10, 2015 @04:03PM (#9866405)
> Which begs the question: where did the correct intuitions come from?

Logic.

> Can't be random; there are billions of wrong ideas and only 1 right one.

It's not random, it's deductions based on previously known truths.

> So some weight has to be given to intuitions, and some props to those who had the right ones. Because that's how progress gets made.

Props are given to those people, they're called scientists. There are no correct intuitions from the vitalists, they're claim is magic... that's not in any way useful.