News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A successful academic faces lifelong debt by anigbrowl on Wednesday December 09, 2009 @01:53PM (#986292)
How dare you. This person did work to get where she is - did you miss all the stuff about working as a waitress and a cleaner? Obviously, you don't consider Native American studies valuable because it's a field with limited commercial application. And so you equate this perceived lack of value with a lack of willingness on her part to do any work, a faulty syllogism if ever I've seen one.

I understand that you believe her field of study to be an unwise economic choice, such that the cost of acquiring her expertise exceeds the commercial potential. To me the problem is that even though students are paying more than ever for school, the perceived value of educators continues to fall. a story like 'girl starts out poor, gets PhD and job at top university' ought to be an inspiration, but now apparently we have to tack on '...stays poor because she picked some frou-frou field of study I don't approve of'.

MBA culture has fucked this country up really badly.

Re:A successful academic faces lifelong debt by patio11 on Wednesday December 09, 2009 @08:24PM (#987070)
Apologies, time zone differences mean I went to bed before I saw this.

For what its worth, I have a cultural studies degree that cost me six figures. (They had a buy one, get one free deal when I got a degree that had typically results in a career.) I'm going to punt on the question of whether Native American studies is valuable or not. Its sort of like ballet dancing -- I don't have any need for it myself, but don't have any malice in my heart for people who like it. (The question of whether it is commercially valuable or not is an empirical one. Empirically, it just isn't.)

I understand that she did a lot of work to get her degree in a commercially suboptimal field and lifestyle career in churning out more holders of degrees in the same field. She thinks that, rather than having to have slaved so hard for that, I should have to slave so hard for that -- read her last paragraph where she wants society to recalibrate its priorities (i.e. tax folks to pay her to get the schooling to do the job that too many people want to do and too few people want to pay for).

Re:A successful academic faces lifelong debt by tptacek on Wednesday December 09, 2009 @02:30PM (#986374)
Her field of study is an unwise economic choice. That part of the comment you're replying to isn't an opinion.
Re:A successful academic faces lifelong debt by anigbrowl on Wednesday December 09, 2009 @02:42PM (#986410)
I'd have to see the college accounts before I'd concede that. If it is so lacking in value, I wonder how come it was so expensive for her to obtain her PhD?
Re:A successful academic faces lifelong debt by scott_s on Wednesday December 09, 2009 @03:06PM (#986462)
Because, as a liberal arts student, she probably didn't have much in the way of assistanceships or scholarships. Most science and engineering students are supported through teaching assistanceships, research assistanceships or fellowships from outside her school. Those pay both tuition and a modest salary.
Re:A successful academic faces lifelong debt by tptacek on Wednesday December 09, 2009 @02:51PM (#986433)
What does one thing have to do with the other? People make irrational economic choices all the time.
Re:A successful academic faces lifelong debt by scott_s on Wednesday December 09, 2009 @03:12PM (#986479)
You misinterpreted his last sentence. He didn't mean "I work for a living, you don't."

He meant "Since both of us come from backgrounds which requires us to work to get through school, we need to pick areas of study that will pay enough to support us."

Re:A successful academic faces lifelong debt by anigbrowl on Wednesday December 09, 2009 @03:32PM (#986521)
As shown elsewhere, teaching computer science doesn't seem to pay all that well either. I think the real problem here is not her chosen field of study but the fact that wages have no kept place with inflation in recent years.

I could go on, but I won't...I don't want this to turn into a Reddit-style argument. My basic position is that undervaluing teaching as a service undermines our educational productivity and long-term economic growth, through excess focus on short-term dividends at the expense of cumulative value.

Re:A successful academic faces lifelong debt by scott_s on Wednesday December 09, 2009 @03:46PM (#986547)
Note that I didn't defend his statement, I clarified what he meant.

But I have to disagree with your first point. I point out elsewhere in this thread that there is a $30k gap between starting salaries for CS and History. Your conclusion may be true (wages have not tracked inflation), but it is not supported by the point you made.

Also keep in mind there are two kinds of professors: professors with research expectations, and professors with only teaching obligations. All professors at my school will have research expectations. Some colleges (often referred to as "teaching colleges," which is sadly not redundant) have no research expectations of their professors, but will pay less.

Re:A successful academic faces lifelong debt by sschronk on Wednesday December 09, 2009 @02:54PM (#986443)
Yes it has.

That's a major problem with the attitude in our country. Greed has overtaken our senses and everyone thinks they are entitled.

Even when you look at the number of students in each major, you will see a very disproportionate number of students majoring in subjects just for the money with a disregard for their talent in the field.

Re:A successful academic faces lifelong debt by pwnstigator on Wednesday December 09, 2009 @02:03PM (#986316)
MBA culture has fucked this country up really badly.

Agree. The idea that you need to be part of an elite, well-connected, largely hereditary caste to do "business" is ridiculous. People much less educated than us, with minimal social connections, have been "doing business" for centuries, and succeeding at it (although not at great scale).

Most people (outside of that caste) are doing support work with minimal importance, crunching data or filling out paperwork for people who, because of their caste status, get to have their mediocre ideas implemented. Of course this is inefficient; they're bored sick.