News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Mystery Behind the Biggest Bitcoin Transaction by irickt on Thursday July 09, 2015 @08:07PM (#9861549)
I read both articles and though I don't understand the mechanics involved I'm left with a big question: Could a a well-financed actor (state or otherwise) simply crash bitcoin with spam?
Re:The Mystery Behind the Biggest Bitcoin Transaction by sanswork on Thursday July 09, 2015 @08:18PM (#9861596)
A marginally financed one could crash a lot of services but the best a well funded one could do with spam is make transactions more expensive for users. A better use of their money would be buying up farms and miner manufacturers and attacking the network that way. A couple hundred million would give you a large enough stake in most manufactures of competitive mining equipment. You could then use this control to route their supply to yourself basically cutting third parties out of the mining business.
Re:The Mystery Behind the Biggest Bitcoin Transaction by ikeboy on Thursday July 09, 2015 @10:08PM (#9861937)
> A better use of their money would be buying up farms and miner manufacturers and attacking the network that way.

Spamming enough to seriously impact the cost of transactions can be done for far less than getting most of the mining power. Probably less than a million, depending on how long you're willing to wait to accumulate coindays and other factors.

Re:The Mystery Behind the Biggest Bitcoin Transaction by sanswork on Thursday July 09, 2015 @10:47PM (#9862044)
You could do it for less than $25k at the moment, probably less than $5k a day if you were clever about the transactions. The second scenario was how a well funded entity could best disrupt it. Spamming transactions is annoying but doesn't really cause too many problems.
Re:The Mystery Behind the Biggest Bitcoin Transaction by ikeboy on Thursday July 09, 2015 @11:08PM (#9862086)
>Spamming transactions is annoying but doesn't really cause too many problems.

If you do it well enough such that there's no simple rule to distinguish them (that could be written in an emergency, as has been suggested), then it seems like it would be a big deal. Who's still using bitcoin when the fees are >$10 per tx?

(I think the eventual solution will involve larger blocksize + proper pruning, and shifting costs to the cost-generators by, for instance, requiring the sender to provide the full input instead of storing it in the utxo database, but so far the existing proposals aren't really complete and well-reviewed enough to be used.)

Edit: oh, and off-chain stuff like lightning.

Re:The Mystery Behind the Biggest Bitcoin Transaction by sanswork on Thursday July 09, 2015 @11:31PM (#9862158)
Napkin math but by the time you're spending enough on transaction fees to be pushing people into the >$10 per tx range to beat you, you'd be over $1m/day. I think at that point you're better off going with my "buy the miners" plan if destruction is your plan.
Re:The Mystery Behind the Biggest Bitcoin Transaction by davidgerard on Friday July 10, 2015 @05:00AM (#9862935)
Speculation on /r/buttcoin is that this is either someone dumping coins and hiding it in the chaff, or a DNM exit scam and someone hiding it in the chaff.

The other interesting thing is that the price went up even though the network was literally unusable. The spam demonstrated that the price of Bitcoin is literally detached from any form of utility whatsoever. The exchange price appears to be dictated by day traders only.

Re:The Mystery Behind the Biggest Bitcoin Transaction by ikeboy on Friday July 10, 2015 @09:57AM (#9863947)
>The spam demonstrated that the price of Bitcoin is literally detached from any form of utility whatsoever.

Why should the price track current utility as opposed to expected? If the market as a whole doesn't expect this spam to have a long-term effect, it won't affect the price.

Re:The Mystery Behind the Biggest Bitcoin Transaction by PhilWright on Thursday July 09, 2015 @08:19PM (#9861604)
Exactly. One of the chief benefits of BitCoin is that you can act in an anonymous manner if you perform your transactions in a careful way. This means it is inherently open to being collapsed by a powerful actor that has the resources and will to attack. Certainly a state but I suspect a relatively small group could do the same.

Being found out as the source of an attack is the biggest deterrent. Without the deterrent the temptation for a vested interest must be a magnitude higher.

Re:The Mystery Behind the Biggest Bitcoin Transaction by nickodell on Thursday July 09, 2015 @09:18PM (#9861797)
>Being found out as the source of an attack is the biggest deterrent.

It doesn't seem like much of a deterrent. Suppose we knew for a fact that the attacker was John Smith in Chicago. How would that deter them?

Re:The Mystery Behind the Biggest Bitcoin Transaction by wildmusings on Thursday July 09, 2015 @09:29PM (#9861831)
Because it's a crime that you can go to prison for. And all of the damaged parties could sue you.
Re:The Mystery Behind the Biggest Bitcoin Transaction by northben on Thursday July 09, 2015 @11:32PM (#9862160)
It's not a crime to create many small transactions...
Re:The Mystery Behind the Biggest Bitcoin Transaction by wildmusings on Friday July 10, 2015 @08:56PM (#9867979)
It is if you do it with the intent to defraud people or to make a service inaccessible. Same thing with a denial of service attack. It's not illegal to visit a webpage, but it is illegal to visit a webpage millions of times per second to bring the server down.
Re:The Mystery Behind the Biggest Bitcoin Transaction by dogma1138 on Thursday July 09, 2015 @10:08PM (#9861939)
How exactly bitcoin transactions are anonymous? Sure they don't have your name tagged on them but they are signed with your key. It won't be that hard to do some data analysis on the block chain to expose who's really behind each transaction, if bitcoin ever goes mainstream it will effectively mean that everyone's creditcard bill will become public...
Re:The Mystery Behind the Biggest Bitcoin Transaction by northben on Thursday July 09, 2015 @11:33PM (#9862163)
Well, modern wallets create new addresses for every transaction. So it's like having a new credit card number for every transaction in your analogy. It's pretty much anonymous.
Re:The Mystery Behind the Biggest Bitcoin Transaction by dogma1138 on Friday July 10, 2015 @09:25AM (#9863778)
And how long does it take to a new address to be accepted by the network? This isn't a viable solution for a large volume day to day usage.
Re:The Mystery Behind the Biggest Bitcoin Transaction by davidgerard on Friday July 10, 2015 @04:57AM (#9862922)
Even a poorly financed actor could crash Bitcoin with spam. The network was jammed to unusability for a couple of days just now for a few hundred to a few thousand dollars' worth of Bitcoin. That's enough that if you had old Bitcoins you didn't care about, you could do it for teh lulz.