1- Over the course of a year I buy and sell hundres of stock issues, constantly incuring taxable events, and at the end I sell off the entire portfolio including short term cap gains rate (same as income rates).
2- I buy an ETF that does all the same trades, but when I sell I only get long term cap gains taxes.
3- I loan a company money (sell an note) to do this trading and a clause written for at the end of the year call the note for a value equal to the previous two scenarios. I incure taxation from a bond investment,
4- I buy an ETN (exchange traded note) that repays based on a formula as if the previous trades were made. Once again I pay long term capital gains on an equity investment.
5- I buy a future on the index I'm managing and invest an an amount equal to current price of the stocks in bonds to replicate the price performance on the ETN. When I sell a year, I incure two taxable events.
6- I have't even brought up options, so I can keep going.
These are all the same, but they all have different taxable events and consider a realized gain something different.
But $10 and ten $1 bills are equivalent. A tax that applied to one and not the other would be very weird; it's not clear what behavior it's meant to encourage, and anyway lots of people would avoid paying it.
So the argument above is that "realizing" gains is a lot like getting change for a dollar bill. I don't know whether that's right, but anyway it's different from arguing about whether money is real :)
What exactly are you trading? Bits in a database that mark ownership of a fraction of a fictional entity?
Please read more carefully. I never claimed any such thing.
'fictional' modifies 'entity', not 'ownership'.
Will need to rethink my involvement here.
Nope (although, that may be true, in some sense), I am not saying that. I am saying the thing many refer to as an 'entity', as in, 'the corporate entity', is a fictional thing. It has no real, inherent or independent physical existence apart from the people that choose to represent it.
Part ownership of a company.
To say anything else is to show yourself to be completely naive.
To believe that all assets are 'part ownership of a company' is not only naive, but incorrect and delusional.
Trading an asset vs. holding it is a non-fictional concept very much grounded in reality.
Attributing significance to it is, in a sense, arbitrary in the same sense that any assignment of significance is, but its definitely not a fictional concept divorced from reality.