News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We've Adapted Our Reading Habits to Fit Our Screens, but ... by kazinator on Thursday July 09, 2015 @11:21AM (#9858343)
Ironically, I skimmed through this, looking for a key sentence in every paragraph. Didn't find much of value.

People need to learn to condense their point, ideally down to one small paragraph or sentence. For instance,

"Without any data to back it up, I have a suspicion that people's reading skills are suffering because they are used to being flooded with writing in the digital world, and so they don't read everything from top to bottom."

I have another opinion, which is this:

People are now reading more than ever (and writing). Thirty years ago, the same types of people wouldn't be reading anything at all, and spend several hours a day in front of a TV. And they wouldn't be writing text messages, but rather using the telephone.

The reason people are non-linearly scanning text is not because they are managing their time poorly. They are managing their time well in the face of poorly organized, information-sparse rambling.

Most writing out there competing for your attention doesn't deserve it, and in writing that does deserve your attention, there are actually only small "hot spots" which do, not everything.

Non-linear reading isn't a degradation in reading skill; it is a valuable skill in it own right. Schools even teach this to kids: how to skim through text to get the gist of the content so that you can focus on what is relevant. (And they taught this before the "digital age".) You need this skill to get through university. When you're doing research, there are just too many books and papers to sit there going word by word.

So, skim on, friends! And raise a big TL;DR middle finger to ramblers (like what I'm becoming here with this comment).

Re:We've Adapted Our Reading Habits to Fit Our Screens, but ... by AnimalMuppet on Thursday July 09, 2015 @12:47PM (#9859054)
You need one more skill: You need to know when skimming didn't give you enough.

I see this with my kids. One of them skimmed the chapter in the math book, then asked me for help with the exercises. My "help" was: "Go back and actually read the chapter. Don't skim it." And that worked.

It can be hard to tell the difference between "there's nothing there worth my time" and "there's something there, and I have to read it more thoroughly to find out what it is." You don't get 100% accuracy at this, but you can (I think) get somewhat good at it.

Re:We've Adapted Our Reading Habits to Fit Our Screens, but ... by kazinator on Thursday July 09, 2015 @07:42PM (#9861439)
You can still trim how much you read when doing chapter exercises. Just start with the exercises and then search backwards for clues when you're stuck on something. Some books have a "chapter summary" which serves as a kind of directory to the details. That is conveniently located between the exercises and the bulk of the chapter: it practically begs to be traversed in that direction. :)
Re:We've Adapted Our Reading Habits to Fit Our Screens, but ... by forgottenpass on Thursday July 09, 2015 @12:14PM (#9858794)
Most writing out there competing for your attention doesn't deserve it, and in writing that does deserve your attention, there are actually only small "hot spots" which do, not everything.

I don't know if digital reading is shrinking my reading attention span, but "long form journalism" sure is. The utility of the journalism in day to day life is already quite low, and the utility is usually correlated with boring and dry. Reading articles written by people who think so highly of their storytelling to waste my time by padding it out made me realize I don't give a fuck. Now I can't help but notice regular news is padded out as well. There is still room in my heart for in depth reporting, but "long form" is a trick to be engaging, just like clickbait but with a fake air of importance.

Re:We've Adapted Our Reading Habits to Fit Our Screens, but ... by kazinator on Thursday July 09, 2015 @03:39PM (#9860218)
I find myself particularly turned off by lengthy introductory paragraphs that begin with some useless generality, anecdote and such: stuff that might be effective in public speaking or writing essays. I know that connecting the material to the real world somehow is important: to provide a bridge to the subject matter which makes it relevant to the readers. But at the same time, I recognize the device and it's just irksome. I've already somehow decided that I'm interested, and landed on the page already; you don't have to waste words convincing me.

Petty Woman [1990 movie] quote sums it up: I appreciate this whole seduction thing you've got going on here, but let me give you a tip: I'm a sure thing.

:)