News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mapping the U.S. By Property Value Instead of Land Area by dasil003 on Wednesday July 08, 2015 @03:30PM (#9854067)
That doesn't quite follow since SF and NYC are already the highest population densities in the US. The fact that the residents don't want to allow greater densities doesn't invalidate the correlation.
Re:Mapping the U.S. By Property Value Instead of Land Area by curun1r on Wednesday July 08, 2015 @07:05PM (#9855196)
Yes, it does. Demand is very different from density. The fact that one region happens to have both high density and high demand is coincidence, not correlation. For it to be a correlation, that would have to be the case in most places. Places like Mountain View, Palo Alto or even Beverly Hills and Malibu also have high demand with a much lower population density.

Also, while it's trite to say, correlation doesn't not mean causation. Being a proxy means a causal relationship, not just a correlation. XKCD was arguing against maps that indicate a causal relationship. Each of the graphs in the comic don't just correlate with population density maps, they're the same because they're visualizing a trait that has no difference based on geography. That's in no way the case in this situation.

Re:Mapping the U.S. By Property Value Instead of Land Area by cynicalkane on Wednesday July 08, 2015 @08:20PM (#9855479)
The densest part of Chicago is approximately as dense as SF, but isn't so astronomically expensive.