Re:Some Functional Programmers Are Arrogant
by Chattered on Wednesday July 08, 2015 @03:16PM
(#9853990)
That FP subtracts from everything else can be switched around pretty easily. If you, as a client, can prove that you do not mutate the data structure that I hand back to you, then I don't have to worry about you corrupting my alias of it, and I don't have to worry about giving you a deep-copy instead of a direct reference.
Pure functional programming subtracts something from your expressive power, but it also subtracts from the assumptions you have to make about code. Less expressive power is a bad thing, but fewer assumptions are a good thing. The inequality of assumption versus conclusion is right there in the functional arrow.
I'm not sure I can easily work the vegetarian analogy into that. Vegetarians notoriously frustrate catering, while I think people who agree never to mutate data are probably easier for programmers to cater for.
Pure functional programming subtracts something from your expressive power, but it also subtracts from the assumptions you have to make about code. Less expressive power is a bad thing, but fewer assumptions are a good thing. The inequality of assumption versus conclusion is right there in the functional arrow.
I'm not sure I can easily work the vegetarian analogy into that. Vegetarians notoriously frustrate catering, while I think people who agree never to mutate data are probably easier for programmers to cater for.