Re:Some Functional Programmers Are Arrogant
by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday July 08, 2015 @01:33PM
(#9853286)
> Here’s the thing about people who are enthusiastic about functional programming. Most of them are just so relieved to find someone showing a genuine interest that they will bend over backwards to help you. To build you up. To make YOU feel smart.
> I know this because I was on the receiving end of this generosity from the moment I showed an interest. This is why it’s frankly baffling when this charge of arrogance is levelled. Why functional programming? Of all the areas of software development, why is the arrogance of functional programmers a thing?
It's not how welcoming FP people are to newcomers. It's how condescending and condemning some FPers are to those who are outside FP. "You're unenlightened/stupid/incompetent/wrong if you don't do it this way." Yes, I have heard that attitude, here on HN, more than once.
Immutable is good. It's not always the right answer, though. Some FP advocates don't seem to get that, and assume (and state) that everyone else is wrong to ever do it any other way. That's arrogant, because it assumes that those who choose some other way cannot possibly have valid reasons.
> I know this because I was on the receiving end of this generosity from the moment I showed an interest. This is why it’s frankly baffling when this charge of arrogance is levelled. Why functional programming? Of all the areas of software development, why is the arrogance of functional programmers a thing?
It's not how welcoming FP people are to newcomers. It's how condescending and condemning some FPers are to those who are outside FP. "You're unenlightened/stupid/incompetent/wrong if you don't do it this way." Yes, I have heard that attitude, here on HN, more than once.
Immutable is good. It's not always the right answer, though. Some FP advocates don't seem to get that, and assume (and state) that everyone else is wrong to ever do it any other way. That's arrogant, because it assumes that those who choose some other way cannot possibly have valid reasons.