News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CVS Health Quits U.S. Chamber Over Stance on Smoking by SilasX on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @05:56PM (#9848373)
I can understand that much, but CVS doesn't (privately) reap the returns from healthier customers. That dynamic would apply to a health insurer or provider, not a glorified convenience store.
Re:CVS Health Quits U.S. Chamber Over Stance on Smoking by dragonwriter on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @06:25PM (#9848513)
> I can understand that much, but CVS doesn't (privately) reap the returns from healthier customers.

Assuming that customer retention is cheaper than acquisition, it directly reaps the returns from not killing its customers.

> That dynamic would apply to a health insurer or provider, not a glorified convenience store.

CVS is, among other things, an insurer (or, rather, a pharmacy benefit management company serving insurers, but the incentives are pretty similar with regard to not killing the insurers customers), and also operates the nations largest walk-in clinic brand in its in-store clinics (so, its also a provider, and not just in the sense that every pharmacy is.)

Re:CVS Health Quits U.S. Chamber Over Stance on Smoking by SilasX on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @07:15PM (#9848772)
>Assuming that customer retention is cheaper than acquisition, it directly reaps the returns from not killing its customers.

Public goods problem -- you have to subtract off all the customers you lose to other companies that have extra money due to not cutting off the cigarette revenue stream.

Re:CVS Health Quits U.S. Chamber Over Stance on Smoking by johnmaguire2013 on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @06:04PM (#9848415)
In fact, wouldn't they lose profits on tobacco cessation products and medications used by smokers with health problems?
Re:CVS Health Quits U.S. Chamber Over Stance on Smoking by larrys on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @06:26PM (#9848520)
Agree. If people smoke and are unhealthy they in theory would need a larger amount of prescription drugs which CVS sells and profits from.
Re:CVS Health Quits U.S. Chamber Over Stance on Smoking by dragonwriter on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @06:32PM (#9848550)
> If people smoke and are unhealthy they in theory would need a larger amount of prescription drugs which CVS sells and profits from.

If people smoke and die sooner, they will in theory (and practice) need no more of the prescription drugs which CVS sells and profits from. Heck, statistics showing that smoking reduces total health care costs (and, less relevantly to the immediate discussion, pension costs) by killing people younger have been used by cigarette smoking companies as part of campaigns against government anti-smoking campaigns around the world.

Aside from the moral aspects of that argument, the financial aspects work exactly the opposite for people selling health care services -- which CVS does, both as a pharmacy and a clinic operator -- as they would on people funding health care costs.

Re:CVS Health Quits U.S. Chamber Over Stance on Smoking by ItsDeathball on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @06:09PM (#9848439)
CVS is actually a health insurer, or at least a component of one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CVS_Health#Strategic_Business_...
Re:CVS Health Quits U.S. Chamber Over Stance on Smoking by refurb on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @07:05PM (#9848719)
CVS is not really an insurer, they are a provider of retail pharmacy, specialty pharmacy, home infusion, etc.

They are actually paid by the insurance companies to provide these services.

Re:CVS Health Quits U.S. Chamber Over Stance on Smoking by hganesan on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @06:51PM (#9848647)
As a PBM, they might actually be making some money back by not supporting tobacco products as well. If the anti-tobacco stance gets an extra health plan or insurer to sign with Caremark, the increased revenue from scripts, and potential added trips from customers, can make up for losses in tobacco-related revenue.

Might also help them position themselves to shift more and more towards being a credible health care service provider.

Re:CVS Health Quits U.S. Chamber Over Stance on Smoking by acomjean on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @06:01PM (#9848399)
alive customers are the best kind.

CVS is a pharmacy so keeping patients alive longer means more money on perscription medication.

Re:CVS Health Quits U.S. Chamber Over Stance on Smoking by Sanddancer on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @06:12PM (#9848453)
By making it harder to maintain bad habits, CVS is looking at long-term goals. Getting a customer to stop smoking means a good probability that they're going to buy more things from CVS in the extra years they live.