News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Zealand is making cyber bullying a specific crime by chroma on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @05:15AM (#9844325)
In your examples, you readily equivocate civil and criminal law. The punishments and standards of evidence differ quite a bit. You also reference US cases that most free speech advocates (including the ACLU) disagree with. Reams could be written teasing out details, but I'll skip over that and get to the core of my disagreement.

I really dislike framing in terms of "freedom of speech." Many of the first lions of free speech: John Milton, Thomas Paine, and John Stuart Mill... they framed it in terms of freedom of hearing. By silencing someone, you limit potential audiences and their right to hear. In this original framing, the rights of these listeners are crucial, not just those of the speaker. Yes, Sturgeon's law applies. Most speech is crap. But let readers and listeners decide for themselves what they should read or hear. Don't give a government body that power.

And honestly, is there any government body you would be willing to grant that power? The power of deciding what you could read or hear? Considering their typical level of competence, can you honestly say you'd be happy with your government being a filter for your senses? Would you be content letting them throw people in jail for nothing more than text typed on a keyboard? Maybe it's my American upbringing, but the concept seems absurd to me. Sticks and stones can break my bones, but... words can be a felony? What the hell?

Edit: I'm not sure how, but many readers seem to have misconstrued my comment as condoning threats. That is not the case. Everyone here agrees that threats to one's well-being are criminal and wrong. The law we are discussing restricts the exchange of ideas, albeit potentially crudely-formed ones. Let's not attack straw men.

Re:New Zealand is making cyber bullying a specific crime by vacri on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @05:23AM (#9844346)
> Sticks and stones can break my bones, but... words can be a felony?

I guess when people live in such fear from online bullying that they have to move house because of the rape and death threats they're receiving, it's a little more than "text typed on a keyboard".

It's not your American upbringing, it's your framing of the problem.

Re:New Zealand is making cyber bullying a specific crime by x0054 on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @05:54AM (#9844448)
All of the examples you and many others in this thread are giving are already illegal, under currently existing laws, in most, if not all countries. Threatening people with violence, encouraging others to commit violence against other people, actually coming over and stalking people. All of those things are crimes already. There is no need to make another law that makes it illegal to do something that is already highly illegal.
Re:New Zealand is making cyber bullying a specific crime by chroma on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @05:39AM (#9844397)
It really should go without saying, but rape and death threats are crimes. Nobody is saying they aren't.

New Zealand's new law isn't about criminalizing such (already illegal) threats. It's about making non-threats crimes. Under this law, half of the comments in this thread could be interpreted as illegal. Hell, I can't think of a comedian that couldn't be charged under this law. That's what I'm up-in-arms about.

Re:New Zealand is making cyber bullying a specific crime by vacri on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @06:01AM (#9844469)
Well... actually you are arguing that they aren't crimes. You are arguing that governments should not be given the power to limit what you see or hear. Threats fall under that umbrella.

You say 'let readers and listeners decide for themselves what they want to hear', but that is exactly the course of action of this legislation. It's not a proactive government censorship stopping any abuse from happening, but a post-facto avenue to pursue for readers and listeners who do feel abused. There is no 'right to hear' being removed here.

Re:New Zealand is making cyber bullying a specific crime by AdeptusAquinas on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @06:01AM (#9844471)
That's very hyperbolic. The law is about threats and abuse - and is actually fairly specific as to what that entails. No one in this thread - or any comedian for that matter - is trying to incite a specific reader to take his or her life. If they were then boom - if this is in NZ there is now a law that will get you locked up.
Re:New Zealand is making cyber bullying a specific crime by chroma on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @06:06AM (#9844486)
> No one in this thread - or any comedian for that matter - is trying to incite a specific reader to take his or her life.

"If you have something to say, here's what you do: You write it down on a piece of paper, you go out in the lobby, and then you go home and you kill yourself."

— Louis C.K. [1]

I and many others found Louis CK's performance hilarious, but what's stopping him from being locked up the next time he performs in New Zealand? It's only fame and prosecutorial discretion that stands between him and a prison sentence.

1. http://www.rollingstone.com/movies/news/how-louis-c-k-became...

Re:New Zealand is making cyber bullying a specific crime by AdeptusAquinas on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @06:22AM (#9844540)
What's stopping him from being locked up is that he is not attacking a specific individual, as the act clearly specifies he would need to for it to be a crime. He isn't pulling aside a member of his audience, then using email or social media in an attempt to get that person to kill themselves. That's what the law is there to prevent.
Re:New Zealand is making cyber bullying a specific crime by vacri on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @10:22AM (#9845589)
That and the fact that New Zealanders aren't fucking idiots. The law states 'reasonable person', not 'if the slightest offense is taken'. It's clearly part of an act, it's clearly not directed at anyone, and it's clearly not meant to be taken seriously.
Re:New Zealand is making cyber bullying a specific crime by chroma on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @05:25PM (#9848215)
While I don't want to disparage all New Zealanders, I'm quite certain there are enough idiotic, overbearing, or corrupt officials that this law will be abused. And I'd like to stake money on this claim.

I am willing to bet 1 bitcoin (≈265 USD), at even odds, that within a year we will see an article on the front page of HN showing abuses of the Harmful Digital Communications Bill. Specific abuses may include: corporate censorship, overreactions to jokes, or people jailed for offhand drunk-posting. There are a myriad of possibilities.

If this happens, you pay me one bitcoin. If this does not happen, I pay you one bitcoin. If you're interested in this bet (or terms similar to it), let me know and I would be happy to discuss details.

I should warn you: The history of these sorts of laws is pretty bad. For example, Malicious Communications Act[1] has been used in all kinds of ridiculous cases. People have been arrested for posting images as pedestrian as a burning poppy.[2]

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malicious_Communications_Act_1...

2. http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2012/nov/12/kent-man-arrested-...

Re:New Zealand is making cyber bullying a specific crime by vacri on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @07:42PM (#9848897)
As other people have noted, Kiwiland is known for more lenient sentencing and doesn't generally throw people in jail over trivial things. It still suffers from the vicissitudes of any legal system - run by humans, they're not perfect - but jail time for 'drunk posting'?

Similarly, I don't like your mechanism for success - a mere article on the front page of HN. For $265, what's to stop you writing an article and submitting it yourself? Your profile page clearly indicates your current handle as being intentionally anonymous so comments can't be traced back to you personally. And if your problem is that the law will be abused, why do you have no qualms in taking any article as being written in good faith, no matter the author?

And, even if you can provide a single counter-example, well, welcome to law. Sometimes false positives happen. That people get falsely convicted of rape or murder laws don't mean that rape or murder laws are an affront to freedom and must be disposed of. Laws are sledgehammers, not scalpels, and coming up with single counter-examples is worthless.

I'm also not personally interested in BTC. It's a farce - it's fun to play with for some and that's cool, but it's never going to be a functional currency. As I don't really find it fun (friends are fans), I've never bothered to get set up properly with it.

To sum up: no, I don't take your bet.

Edit: Writing your own article would actually be worth $530, since that's the delta between paying out and collecting winnings.

Re:New Zealand is making cyber bullying a specific crime by elemenopy on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @06:35AM (#9844569)
> It's only fame and prosecutorial discretion that stands between him and a prison sentence.

That a complete misrepresentation of how this law works. If Louis C.K. created a digital communication which contravened Principle 9 ('do not incite others to commit suicide') [1] then the victim might complain to the Approved Agency, which is presently Netsafe NZ [2], who mediates between Louis C.K. and the complainant.

If mediation is unsuccessful and Netsafe believes it is warranted Louis C.K. could be referred to the District Court, who hears submissions and makes orders as it deems necessary per s 11 [3] including referring the complaint back to Netsafe for further mediation. If the Court makes an order (e.g., 'remove the communication') and Louis C.K. refuses to comply he may be fined, or at the extreme end be sentenced to six months imprisonment [4] which in New Zealand would be served as home detention.

The New Zealand justice system is typically fairly lenient and lacks most of the mandatory sentencing requirements of the U.S. justice system. The District Court would not impose any significant fine or home detention unless the offending was at the extreme end of the scale, e.g. Louis C.K. incited a specific vulnerable individual to commit suicide in front of a large audience and they subsequently attempted to do so.

There is a lot more than 'prosecutorial discretion' between Louis C.K. and a prison sentence. This law is far from perfect, and maybe it'd be better if it didn't exist at all, but it's not imposing the insane wholesale restrictions on free speech that is being suggested throughout this thread.

1. http://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/2015/0063/latest/w... 2. http://www.netsafe.org.nz/ 3. http://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/2015/0063/latest/w... 4. http://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/2015/0063/latest/w...

Re:New Zealand is making cyber bullying a specific crime by pjc50 on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @05:36AM (#9844384)
Would you be content letting them throw people in jail for nothing more than text typed on a keyboard?

a) This can be extremely deadly. Enough hate speech can lead to real violence. Europe knows this from horrible experience. A modern example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radio_T%C3%A9l%C3%A9vision_Lib...

b) Don't pretend that America doesn't have free speech restrictions in the legal system. The most egregious example is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food_libel_laws , but there are also plenty of national security related ones. Try sending some death threats to the President and see what happens.

c) We really need to distinguish between saying things to people which a third party doesn't want discussed (the freedom of hearing case) and saying things to someone which that person doesn't want to hear. I don't think you can invoke Mill to give you unlimited freedom to send death and rape threats to strangers on the internet.

Re:New Zealand is making cyber bullying a specific crime by venomsnake on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @05:41AM (#9844403)
> saying things to someone which that person doesn't want to hear.

You know you can put fingers in your ears, right?

Re:New Zealand is making cyber bullying a specific crime by pjc50 on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @06:22AM (#9844543)
This is the "if you didn't want to get abuse from white people you should have sat at the back of the bus" / "you should have known that being a prominent woman on twitter would get you daily rape threats" argument. As others are saying, it's not costless, in fact its quite damaging to the psyche.

Because you can't know, until communication starts, whether it's going to be vicious. And you can't walk around with your fingers in your ears all the time.

Some internet services get this, but it's awfully easy for people to generate new accounts to route abuse through.

We could do well to develop anti-abuse technology in the same mode as anti-spam.

Re:New Zealand is making cyber bullying a specific crime by venomsnake on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @06:30AM (#9844562)
> And you can't walk around with your fingers in your ears all the time.

I can only assume you have not talked with antivaxxers, climate change deniers or people taking their religion too seriously.

Whether insult hurts or not is your choice. If you have such weak control over your inner world - learn to not give a fuck. not that hard.

Re:New Zealand is making cyber bullying a specific crime by elemenopy on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @06:56AM (#9844646)
> Whether insult hurts or not is your choice.

This is nonsense. If you are subjected to continuous, vitriolic, realistic rape threats on Twitter then this is inevitably going to stress you and make you feel somewhat unhappy or unsafe. But if you are a 14-year-old, or otherwise particularly vulnerable, then they may cause acute depression or suicide.

This Act isn't about antivaxxers or climate change deniers. It is about revenge porn and vicious cyberbullying, and I am not prepared to stand up for either.

Re:New Zealand is making cyber bullying a specific crime by onion2k on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @10:21AM (#9845583)
Whether insult hurts or not is your choice. If you have such weak control over your inner world - learn to not give a fuck. not that hard.

The problem here is that most people who suggest 'just ignore it' as a solution haven't ever faced the sort of abuse that the proposed law is designed to deal with. You're quite right that it's easy to ignore an insult. It's much harder to ignore a believable death or rape threat, racist remark, misogyny, etc. That is what you're suggesting people should 'learn to not give a fuck' about. As someone who believes quite strongly that we shouldn't just ignore those things and that we should actively try to stop them, I find your argument incomprehensible.

Re:New Zealand is making cyber bullying a specific crime by venomsnake on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @10:50AM (#9845780)
While ignoring a believable (whatever that means) death treat is probably hard, why put racism, misandry and misogeny in the same stuff - you are totally free to talk to the harassers back - find what makes them sensitive and make them hurt. You have the same tools as them. Make a psychological profile, find what makes them tick and talk back in a way to inflict maximum hurt feelz.
Re:New Zealand is making cyber bullying a specific crime by Tomte on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @05:46AM (#9844418)
"Would you be content letting them throw people in jail for nothing more than text typed on a keyboard?"

Yes! Of course!

Your line of argument is exactly like "I didn't kill him. I just moved my hands which happened to hold a knife which happened to travel through his chest."

Outcome matters. Intent matters.

Deconstructing real actions until some supposedly bizarre conclusion is reached does not matter.

Re:New Zealand is making cyber bullying a specific crime by EliRivers on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @05:30AM (#9844364)
Living in fear is soul destroying. It colours everything you do, everything you think. Every knock at the door provokes a horrible fear reaction. You can't think straight. You plan your life around your fear to an extent that, if it was alcohol or drugs, you'd be recognised as a serious addict and people would try to get you medical intervention.

Living in fear destroys lives. And for what? So some idiot sack of shit can feel like a big man for scaring people? Why exactly should that be permitted?