Nominated for the new entry in Wikipedia to illustrate 'false dichotomy'.
Really, was that the best alternative to one kind of war that you could come up with, another kind of war?
The idea that peace happens when all you see is war is historically very much untrue.
The idea that we have less dead when access to any kind of arms is heavily restricted, how about that?
I think we disagree on how important that 'almost' is as a result, and what the alternative was / is.
But the nuclear game theorist's argument has always been that while functionally more dangerous (i.e. life on this planet could be obliterated at any moment), a nuclear-tipped détente has greater stability than any alternative (i.e. it is least likely to lead to hostilities).
I see the argument for nuclear de-foresting a lot like the argument against nuclear power. Yes, at face value it seems an obvious best option. However, when compared to the realistic alternatives, other approaches may be preferable.
It also allows both sides to maintain a minimal standing army while maximizing the cost of an opponent initiating hostilities. Most of the West's strategic nuclear position has historically been to counter an overwhelming Warsaw Pact numerical advantage in European conventional forces.
It's incredible how people pretend deterrence is for social benefit. It brought us already once near a global atomic war. Remember?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuban_Missile_Crisis
We would live in a better world without nuclear arms, that I'm 100% sure of.