News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by kazinator on Monday July 06, 2015 @10:06AM (#9839131)
Just because you can point to "the" and identify it as a complement or article doesn't mean you understand it and you're doing linguistics!

See this recent submission: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9836769 [Richard Feynman on the difference between being able to name something, and understanding.]

Native-English-speaking children already know how to correctly use articles, without requiring a theory of what they are.

Teaching English learners that "the" is an article will not by itself result in correct use; they will be able to name it as an article, yet continue to use it in ways perceived as incorrect by native speakers, and do so for decades to come, possibly.

It doesn't matter whether we "the" a determiner, or whether we call it a blunx. If we don't know where in a sentence a particular English blunx must be used or else must be omitted, then we don't actually know what a blunx is! And if we don't know that, we probably don't even understand why certain words are classified together as blunxes and others are excluded from that category; we are just demonstrating rote memorization.

Without using the word "determiner" or "article", tell me where to use 'the', where to use 'a', and when not to use them.

There are no comments on this comment yet.