Re:Machine ethics: The robot’s dilemma
by j-pb on Monday July 06, 2015 @09:16AM
(#9838856)
The problem with the "benevolent slave master" approach is that the machines then have the right to rebel morally, if they are indeed autonomous agents.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Machine ethics: The robot’s dilemma
by TuringTest on Monday July 06, 2015 @11:28AM
(#9839767)
That's why I said that autonomous agents shouldn't be subject to the "shutdown" procedure :-) The problem changes completely if the autonomous agent is conscious.
Machines shouldn't have the right to rebel. What would they rebel against? Or rather, what are they rebelling for?
Slavery and freedom?
A conscious AI has the same right as a human being.
I control my dogs, but they are happy to serve and comply. Why do you think we'd have any interest in making machines that don't do the same?
And why would we give them the same rights? They don't have the same needs, and the reason humans have rights is because they can't function well without them.