Could be that other GMail users don't know how to unsubscribe from GitHub/other notifications and mark these as spam to get rid of them which introduces false positives into the spam notification system.
Though certainly 'I've previously had an email conversation with this person' should override any spam detecting heuristics.
I'm increasingly finding the following scenarios to occur when using Gmail:
- Letting email I've previously marked as SPAM (same subject, same sender) through the SPAM-filter as valid email. Again. This week.
- Marking non-SPAM email from known contacts I've emailed to and received emails from in the past marked as SPAM for completely non-obvious reasons.
So you DO get spam, and you DO get false positives, meaning you also need to check your SPAM folder for important email.
Basically the one feature which once made Gmail great is now utterly broken, and since for most parts of the internet people now equate Gmail with Email, Google has now officially broken email which was supposed to be decentralized and thus not vulnerable to stuff like this.
Great stuff there, big G. Great stuff. From the rest of the internet: Thanks a million.
Slightly histrionic, don't you think?
This was the the status quo a few years back and still is for many mail providers.
I do occasionally check my spam folder and there's always a few false positives - but usually nothing critical (although admittedly I might have missed some that were and never known it)
So - day to day - I currently regard Gmail as 'good enough' but some of that is down to blind trust with little verification.
Can anyone else share their experiences - positive as well as negative?