News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fix Reddit with Bitcoin by flashman on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:07AM (#9837084)
How would this system approach, say, child pornography? If it is truly decentralised, then there is no way to keep such content off the network. But there must be a way for users/nodes to avoid hosting or encountering such content, otherwise the risk of participating in its distribution, even with plausible deniability, makes 'Reddit on the blockchain' a legal/moral/ethical non-starter.
Re:Fix Reddit with Bitcoin by c_prompt on Monday July 06, 2015 @09:18AM (#9838873)
You could have flags for CP and then download content with a zero CP flag score. It could work similar to centralized spam providers where you check an IP or username before they post or register. If they have a spam score higher than x, you don't allow them to post or register.
Re:Fix Reddit with Bitcoin by lcswi on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:36AM (#9837185)
You could have a shared blacklist.
Re:Fix Reddit with Bitcoin by yafujifide on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:37AM (#9837194)
If you have a reason to be suspicious of some content, don't downloaded it. If you discover some content is illegal and you have already downloaded it, delete it and don't send it to anyone else. This is probably best handled with a flagging system. Such a system would not be perfect, but could be improved with time.
Re:Fix Reddit with Bitcoin by Nursie on Monday July 06, 2015 @06:06AM (#9837957)
In many countries, UK included, you have already broken the law and could go to prison over that.
Re:Fix Reddit with Bitcoin by rlpb on Monday July 06, 2015 @07:06AM (#9838173)
Re:Fix Reddit with Bitcoin by Nursie on Monday July 06, 2015 @07:12AM (#9838204)
It's not rubbish. At the time the laws were last tightened there were serious discussion to the effect that simply being sent illegal images via email would be enough to get a conviction.

I'm not saying it's a good law.

Even if mens rea applies to this area of law, it includes categories of recklessness and negligence, which could quite easily be argued along the lines of "you were browsing an unregulated P2P network that is known for containing contraband images".

Re:Fix Reddit with Bitcoin by rlpb on Monday July 06, 2015 @07:37AM (#9838323)
> "there were serious discussion to the effect..."

Ah, unsubstantiated claims of Internet speculation over something? That must make it true!

> I'm not saying it's a good law.

What law? Where?

> ...it includes categories of recklessness and negligence, which could quite easily be argued along the lines of "you were browsing an unregulated P2P network that is known for containing contraband images".

"You were browsing the Internet, which is unregulated and is known for containing contraband images".

In reality, you filter when you browse the Internet, and that defines your intent. The same would apply here. Access the "HN" sub-P2P-reddit for unflagged posts then nobody can claim that you had intent. If the "HN" becomes rife with unflagged contraband and you stop using it when this starts to happen as a consequence, then nobody can claim that you had intent.

If the whole network becomes unusable because it's rife with off-topic unflagged contraband, then what you really have is a different argument. You'd be claiming that the network would be unsable because of off-topic unflagged contraband. You wouldn't have any argument about the risk of criminal liability from unintended contraband download, because no law-abiding user would ever get that far.

In short: if functional network then no legitimate risk.