Re:The ICANN Public Comments on WHOIS Privacy
by geofft on Monday July 06, 2015 @01:51AM
(#9837034)
> A: Yes. In many jurisdictions, a business must disclose the actual name and address of the business behind a web site, or be guilty of a criminal offense.
So, why should ICANN enforce this? Especially since this is not true of all jurisdictions -- but even if it were, why is it useful for ICANN to be involved in enforcing individual national or sub-national laws? Shouldn't the standard legal process of law enforcement (and lawmaking, if necessary) in each jurisdiction cover this? What is ICANN's role in enforcing criminal law?
What happens if California repeals that law? Should ICANN still have these requirements?
> See California Business and Professions Code section 17538, which reads: "[...] the vendor shall disclose to the buyer[...]"
This section doesn't seem to have a requirement for the vendor to disclose their information to the general public, nor does it seem to have a requirement for the buyer to disclose their information to the vendor, let alone the general public.
For instance, as you mention, ad-supported websites may or may not be considered commercial. I may be willing to disclose my legal name and street address to my advertisers, but not to my site readers.
> Any site which accepts payments, offers items for sale, or engages in transactions of value should be considered commercial.
Isn't this at odds with your prior claim that individuals have privacy rights that business do not? If I set up a tip jar via Stripe or PayPal for my open-source project, am I now a business?
And, again, what about private individuals who make payments? If I log into a website using OpenID based on my personal domain name, and buy something with a credit card, has my domain name now become a site that "engages in transactions of value"?
It seems like we should have good answers to these questions before adding additional requirements. Again, in the absence of a clear reason why law enforcement needs ICANN's help, the fact that criminal law requires things is not, by itself, a reason for ICANN to urgently require things. Criminal law will take care of itself.
So, why should ICANN enforce this? Especially since this is not true of all jurisdictions -- but even if it were, why is it useful for ICANN to be involved in enforcing individual national or sub-national laws? Shouldn't the standard legal process of law enforcement (and lawmaking, if necessary) in each jurisdiction cover this? What is ICANN's role in enforcing criminal law?
What happens if California repeals that law? Should ICANN still have these requirements?
> See California Business and Professions Code section 17538, which reads: "[...] the vendor shall disclose to the buyer[...]"
This section doesn't seem to have a requirement for the vendor to disclose their information to the general public, nor does it seem to have a requirement for the buyer to disclose their information to the vendor, let alone the general public.
For instance, as you mention, ad-supported websites may or may not be considered commercial. I may be willing to disclose my legal name and street address to my advertisers, but not to my site readers.
> Any site which accepts payments, offers items for sale, or engages in transactions of value should be considered commercial.
Isn't this at odds with your prior claim that individuals have privacy rights that business do not? If I set up a tip jar via Stripe or PayPal for my open-source project, am I now a business?
And, again, what about private individuals who make payments? If I log into a website using OpenID based on my personal domain name, and buy something with a credit card, has my domain name now become a site that "engages in transactions of value"?
It seems like we should have good answers to these questions before adding additional requirements. Again, in the absence of a clear reason why law enforcement needs ICANN's help, the fact that criminal law requires things is not, by itself, a reason for ICANN to urgently require things. Criminal law will take care of itself.