News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by peterfirefly on Sunday July 05, 2015 @11:00PM (#9836477)
> it's not really "wrong" to say "the" is an adjective: it functions exactly like one!

The, theer, theest? The, more the, most the?

The shoe was red but most importantly, it was the. She had never before seen so the a shoe!

In the clearing was old a house with smoke rising from stone the chimney.

Edit: couldn't decide on the number of shoes so I went for both singular and plural :(

Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by SilasX on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:21PM (#9841075)
Fair enough -- "exactly" was overreaching. But depending on circumstance, you may not need to distinguish adjectives from articles. For example, if you're writing something that turns text into an internal semantic model, then "the" gets lumped in with "large" as something that modifies a following noun.

It's still a judgment call whether they properly belong in different categories, and situation-dependent, so it's really not something that merits the "point and laugh" treatment.

Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by Cushman on Sunday July 05, 2015 @11:30PM (#9836583)
Not to sincerely defend the claim that "the" "is" an adjective, but rather to dispute the general notion that grammar is "real": Here are some adjectives that fail your tests.

> The, theer, theest? The, more the, most the?

* Worstest? Most least?

> The shoe was red but most importantly, it was the. She had never before seen so the a shoe!

* The smallest shoe confused her. How could it be so smallest?!

> In the clearing was old a house with smoke rising from stone the chimney.

* Outside the wooden red house was a brick grey ancient barn.

The last one is especially interesting-- if you're a native English speaker, I'll wager that "brick ancient barn" sounds nearly as ungrammatical as "brick the barn", but it's a lot harder to explain why.

Edit: Some more decisive examples of that from replies, since some have rightly pointed out that "brick ancient barn" is semi-acceptable in context:

* "grain lone silo", "fish dry pond", "beef tasty stew", "laptop lost bag", "horse leather saddle" / "leather horse saddle" (both grammatical, but different meanings)

Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by philsnow on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:39AM (#9836816)
> Outside the wooden red house was a brick grey ancient barn.

native speakers of english will find that "red wooden house" is favored over "wooden red house", the same way the "big red dog" is favored over "red big dog".

There's an ordering to adjectives that has something to do with how important the adjective is to the identity or distinctiveness of the modified object.

Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by belovedeagle on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:07AM (#9836713)
The first two (worstest/most least, so smallest) are easily classified as wrong because "-est", "most", and "so" only apply to adjectives of positive degree rather than comparative or superlative. So to deny that grammar is "real" using these examples is to attack a strawman.
Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by Cushman on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:09AM (#9836722)
Oh, I get what you're saying-- so "the" must be a superlative adjective, right? Makes sense really, as it's the "most specific" article.
Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by belovedeagle on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @09:35PM (#9849272)
... no, quite the opposite. Since grammar has no reason to prefer large classification sets (generalization) to small (uniqueness), unlike descriptive linguistics, I'm perfectly happy to say that grammatically "the" is an article and leave it at that.
Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by lnanek2 on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:00AM (#9836684)
Actually there's an order you are supposed to apply things like that. Maybe someone came up with it after the fact, but there is a determinative way to make a list of adjectives sound right.
Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by plorkyeran on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:19AM (#9836744)
"brick grey ancient barn" is grammatically correct if you assume "brick grey" is a color, but of course that's probably not what it's supposed to mean.
Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by Cushman on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:41AM (#9836824)
Indeed! Although I'd argue that probably is what it's supposed to mean.

A "leather horse saddle" and a "horse leather saddle" are very different things, and no native English speaker would mix them up. You know which they mean.

Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by falsedan on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:51AM (#9836866)
What's your point?
Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by jschwartzi on Monday July 06, 2015 @06:16AM (#9838006)
That one is for horses, and the other is from horses.
Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by falsedan on Tuesday July 07, 2015 @12:53AM (#9843696)
As any fule kno
Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by peterfirefly on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:26AM (#9836764)
Time flies like an arrow. Fruit flies like a banana.
Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by dsfas on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:24AM (#9836760)
"Worstest" seems to be a morphological problem. "Most least" could be permissible, if somewhat exotic sounding, I think, if "least" is read with its adjectival meaning―"used in names of very small animals and plants, e.g., least shrew"―so eg. most least shrew. "So smallest" doesn't work with any other superlative ("most reddest") that I can imagine off the top of my head. And "brick ancient barn" is an unusual order but not ungrammatical, though it is interesting. (It sounds more like listing adjectives, ie. I'd read a larger pause after "brick" and stress on "ancient", than the other order. MATERIAL AGE NOUN seems to read awkwardly.)
Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by Cushman on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:30AM (#9836779)
If "brick ancient barn" is too plausible for you to get the full effect, try something with more diverse adjectives like "beef tasty stew" or "laptop lost bag".
Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by thaumasiotes on Monday July 06, 2015 @04:30AM (#9837613)
You really do like fake examples. Can you point to a syntactician making the argument that the "beef" of "beef stew", or the "laptop" of "laptop bag", is an adjective? In any context I'm familiar with, that person would be laughed out of the room.
Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by Cushman on Monday July 06, 2015 @01:10PM (#9840565)
Fair point, apart from the invective. How do you feel about "hiking worn boots" or "mixed-breed adorable puppy"?
Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by thaumasiotes on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:02PM (#9840957)
"Hiking boots" has the same problem -- the boots aren't themselves hiking, they're boots for use in hiking. That's another noun-noun compound.

"Mixed-breed puppy" is, to me, not such a clear case ("breed" is clearly originally a noun, but maybe this use is common enough to have converted). But you don't need to use spurious examples -- in another comment, you provided a very genuine one: "red" and "wooden" are both clearly adjectives, and their ordering cannot vary. This is a well-known example of a somewhat-but-not-entirely mysterious phenomenon in linguistics.

Here's a nice recent writeup of what I think is a related phenomenon: https://stancarey.wordpress.com/2015/04/28/cutthroat-compoun... . This one consists of the observation that words like "kickass" and "pickpocket" are suppressed (not illegal, but suppressed) in English because they conflict with our tendency toward right-headedness (that is, in any English compound, the "essence" of the compound should be found at the right end). Instead, we incline more to compounds like "bank robber" or "nose-thumbing" ("engage in a bit of nose-thumbing"). Someone else in this thread already mentioned that they see adjective ordering as a question of which adjectives are more essential to the whole.

My problem with your comments here is that you're making arguments based on obviously spurious tests unrelated to the claims you then try to follow (um, lead) with. It's analogous to saying "We need to stop celebrating Thanksgiving by eating turkey. Turkey perpetrated the Armenian genocide, genocide is bad and should be stopped, QED". Stick to honest examples, and you'll find the problems you're talking about are rather muted. Don't let your feeling that the problems are large, and you therefore need extremely malformed examples, lead you into choosing examples that are extremely malformed because they exhibit a completely different problem.

Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by Cushman on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:05PM (#9841434)
Well, yeah, I jumped in to defend the idea that the word "the" counts as an adjective. It seems vaguely possible that my argument is not backed by much besides bluster. (And of course the downvotes are my just reward.)

To the extent I'm arguing something non-disingenuous, it's just that language is best analyzed with a bit of a fuzzy lens, and words don't fit into neat boxes.

Take your claim that "hiking" is a noun: To me, it analyzes as an inflection of a verb ("hike") that can be used to indicate an action ("I was hiking"), the performer or target of an action ("I don't hate hiking, hiking hates me") or as a modifier for something else ("those crummy old worn-out tan leather gusseted hiking boots").

On what basis do you say that it is a noun? Specifically, when looking at the list "crummy old worn-out tan leather gusseted hiking", with modifiers lined up in order of significance, what about the word "hiking" jumps out at you as plainly different in use or meaning? "The boots aren't hiking, they're for hiking"? Clearly-- in this phrase, the word "hiking" means the boots are for hiking!

To me, the most intellectually honest thing is to see compound nouns as a sort of epicycle-style theory to explain why words in our non-modifier class are actually used as modifiers all the time, just according to a subtly different set of rules than applies to the modifier class. I don't think there's anything really wrong with that, since it explains things well enough and we might never have something like universal gravitation to set the record straight.

What I'm saying is, I don't think I have a problem.

Except, of course, when the "rules of grammar" are used as a proxy to cast minorities and lower-class people as unintelligent. That, I have a problem with, and it's quite a popular pastime in the English-speaking world. That's why I think it's important to think scientifically about the extent to which grammar is, and is not, a real thing. (Including, sometimes, hypothesizing things that don't make sense, just to see what happens.)

Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by thaumasiotes on Monday July 06, 2015 @03:40PM (#9841678)
> Take your claim that "hiking" is a noun: To me, it analyzes as an inflection of a verb ("hike")

I wouldn't say you're wrong about this. However, I'd be much more willing to defend the idea that, as it appears here, "hiking" is a one-word noun phrase containing a verb form (and that compound nouns are formed NP-NP, not N-N). Traditional grammar has gifted us with a rich vocabulary of specialized terms for specialized syntactic functions, and the traditional term for a verb form which functions as a noun is "gerund". (Um, technically, infinitive forms can also function as nouns.)

I'll pause here to defend myself from an argument you haven't made: there are people who will say that "beef" in "beef stew" is an adjective simply because it modifies a noun. They're wrong. I say that a gerund really is a verb form acting as a noun. The difference is that I'm saying that gerunds can appear in basically all syntactic contexts that permit noun phrases, so the definition I'm using is syntactic (as appropriate for a syntactic term of art like "noun") rather than semantic. I'm not saying gerunds are nouns because they refer to objects -- I'm saying they're nouns because they can be the subjects of verbs (and otherwise appear where nouns appear). To me, the best analysis is just that noun phrases can be constructed from verb forms. Linking back to the subject at hand, I'd agree that "hiking", the word, is not a noun in the same way that "iron", the word, is one, but I am saying that this "hiking", as used in context, is just as much of a noun phrase as "this rusted iron" is.

> Specifically, when looking at the list "crummy old worn-out tan leather gusseted hiking", with modifiers lined up in order of significance, what about the word "hiking" jumps out at you as plainly different in use or meaning?

In all honesty, what jumps out at me is that all of the others are descriptions, while it would be odd to use "hiking" that way. For example, in a certain style of speech, you could see something like this:

    Get out and take your crummy, old, worn-out, leather, gusseted, boots with you.
(In actual rhetoric, the descriptors would probably be different.)

But it's completely impossible for the "hiking" of "hiking boots" to be delimited by commas (in speech, emphatic pauses) that way. If you did it, the meaning of "hiking" would change -- it would mean that the boots were out on a hike. This demonstrates that "hiking" is not a descriptor for "boots" -- rather, "hiking boots" is a single unit. (Yes, with internal structure.)

> To me, the most intellectually honest thing is to see compound nouns as a sort of epicycle-style theory to explain why words in our non-modifier class are actually used as modifiers all the time, just according to a subtly different set of rules than applies to the modifier class.

English is way more liberal with modifiers than that.

    He gave me his I'm-going-to-kill-you look.
I agree that language requires a bit of a fuzzy lens. But grammar is very much a real thing.
Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by tokipin on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:07AM (#9836711)
I wager it's consensus that determines what sequence of words is considered "proper" or not. Personally I have very generous criteria for what a reasonable sentence is. Thought experiment: Reversed words of sequence the with but us for valid as count would that anything be to sentence valid a define.

When we're young we absorb language the way we experience it, in an informal and cultural way. I think in any attempt to categorize aspects of language this basic character has to be respected (which it is in linguistics, being fundamental to it, but which it isn't in e.g. English canon).

Accepting that one's language is actually a messy evolution-convolution of ancient languages is easier for some than others. :D

Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by pests on Sunday July 05, 2015 @11:55PM (#9836665)
Wait, what exactly is wrong about the last one? It sounds odd, but not so incorrect, to me.
Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by peterfirefly on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:02AM (#9836692)
It is perfectly grammatical if "brick" is taken to be a verb.

Edit: this is in reference to "brick the barn". Grammatical if nonsensical. "Brick ancient barn" is of course weird and wrong unless you really want to emphasize that this is a brick ancient barn and not a wooden ancient barn like all the other ancient barns. The normal adjective order can be deviated from for emphasis. My point was that that didn't work when "the" was one of the "adjectives".

(I've been trying to fall asleep for hours so I make mistakes left and right -- I apologize for not being clear about the word list I referred to.)

Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by Cushman on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:24AM (#9836758)
Not to keep you up, but what's even cooler is that the degree to which you can deviate depends on the adjective's class, too. While I can sorta see "brick ancient barn" working, albeit with such heavy emphasis on "brick" that "ancient barn" turns into a bit of a compound, "grain lone silo" or "fish dry pond" don't sound grammatical to me at all. Maybe also because "grain silo" and "fish pond" are almost-notquite compounds?
Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by peterfirefly on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:49AM (#9836860)
That ship has sailed. It's 06:40 and the sun has been pouring through my windows for more than an hour :/ The part of my body that has synched up with the daylight refuses to listen to the part that needs sleep.

--

"Grain silo" and "fish pond" are exactly-precisely compound nouns. It's just that English refuses to accept that it's a Germanic language and instead puts on airs. Honest languages would of course never dream of inserting pretentious spaces between the constituent parts.

I actually thought of "stone chimney" as a compound noun instead of adjective + noun when I wrote it, precisely because I wanted to mock that and really hammer home the point. Unfortunately, the two look the same in English (but not in Danish) -- and I was tired -- so I didn't catch it and replace it with a better example.

Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by Cushman on Monday July 06, 2015 @02:17PM (#9841049)
> "Grain silo" and "fish pond" are exactly-precisely compound nouns.

Eeeh, not exactly in English. English does make some distinction between fully compounded words and noun phrases, especially in rules of production. In a newer phrase like "wind farm", you can swap in more or less any noun you like, even if it doesn't make a lot of sense: "mud farm", "rock farm", "hair farm"... there's some rule like "substance + farm = a farm that produces that substance". With a word like "bedroom", you can get "bathroom", but not so much "deskroom"; there's no general rule like "furniture + room = room where that furniture is found". The space (in cases where it's pronounced) is kinda your hint there.

Anyway... I still don't believe in grammar, but y'all have mounted a spirited defense of the traditional analysis. I'm sorry I tried to say everything's an adjective :)

Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by thaumasiotes on Monday July 06, 2015 @04:32AM (#9837618)
English draws this distinction for gold, with gold (n) and golden (adj).
Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by peterfirefly on Monday July 06, 2015 @04:56AM (#9837712)
I actually meant: written in one word (stonechimney, a compound noun) or not (stone chimney, not a compound noun).
Re:What part of speech is “the”? (2006) by henrikschroder on Monday July 06, 2015 @12:05AM (#9836705)
http://www.gingersoftware.com/content/grammar-rules/adjectiv...

Most people would be comfortable saying "ancient grey brick barn".