News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dune, 50 years on by ende on Saturday July 04, 2015 @02:35AM (#9829454)
What Tolkien was largely dismissing is the notion that his world was a direct allegory. He readily acknowledges that the comraderie and sacrifice he experienced in the trenches of WWI manifests itself in Frodo and his companions, as well as the doomed but defiant determination of the people of England/Gondor in the face of assured destruction, etc. So there are themes that bind the two worlds but he was adamantntly dismissive of any direct mappings (ie Germany as Mordoe or whatever).

Really LotR is about mortality and power.

Re:Dune, 50 years on by ajslater on Friday July 17, 2015 @07:57PM (#9906021)
I believe Tolkien directly said it was about mortality, and that power was a sideshow to move the plot along.

The power of the ring is primarily to delay the inevitable and it corrupts all who cannot accept that.

Re:Dune, 50 years on by johnchristopher on Saturday July 04, 2015 @02:43AM (#9829466)
I am pretty sure there is a passage in the Carter's biography where he clearly states that people drawing parallels between Sauron and Hitler or the West vs the East are idiots.