News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Yet Another Language Speed Test – Counting Primes by whoopdedo on Saturday July 04, 2015 @12:19AM (#9829178)

    Notably, it should be mentioned that writing idiomatic
    Python and Ruby results in much slower code than that 
    used here. Ranges bad. While loops good. 
I get 33% shorter times when I change the while loops to for-in-range and a list comprehension.

But unless you're doing computationally expensive operations, I don't see the benefit of these speed tests except to provide ammunition for flame wars. What good is it for your code to run 50% faster if you spend 300% more time creating, debugging, and maintaining it?

Re:Yet Another Language Speed Test – Counting Primes by alialkhatib on Saturday July 04, 2015 @12:54AM (#9829268)
I'm glad you brought this up, because I was thinking about it but felt like my relative unfamiliarity with C(++) and a handful of other languages in this "shoot-out" made my understanding here flawed (or at least partially naive). I'm also going to piggyback a bit because another thought I had seems related.

There's also the issue that among languages like Python, standard libraries (like multiprocessing[0]) make parallelizing code trivial (even with/despite the dreaded global interpreter lock). I rewrote some of the code the author uses and on a smaller number (6710886 instead of 67108864) I'm seeing ~1/3 the time to run compared to his baseline with 4 worker processes (27.469517s vs 1:25.373176). I haven't looked into what might be keeping it from being a full 4x faster, but my hunch is that it's a combination of other things going on in my laptop and the undeniable difference in execution speed in cPython (specifically, cPython3.4).

One might make the argument that this is a wildly unfair comparison, but my bigger-picture argument is that a language that abstracts things like parallelization to the point that one can invoke such features in a line or two of added & changed code is probably worth factoring into an analysis, if we're even interested in analyzing languages in this way.

If we're going to write C-like code and run it as Python, should we be surprised when it doesn't live up to those expectations?

[0]: https://docs.python.org/3.4/library/multiprocessing.html

Re:Yet Another Language Speed Test – Counting Primes by stelund on Saturday July 04, 2015 @10:22AM (#9830215)
Maybe too low chunksize value for map_async call?