Re:Gemnote (YC S15) Saves Companies from Cheesy Gift Baskets
by ashleyw0ng on Friday July 03, 2015 @03:03PM
(#9827349)
People always ask me about that movie! It's pretty different how they do it--Joaquin composed the letters for people. We don't do that. We let you write the meaningful message instead. It's much more personal. :)
Re:Gemnote (YC S15) Saves Companies from Cheesy Gift Baskets
by ashleyw0ng on Friday July 03, 2015 @05:16PM
(#9827993)
Also related...I think it's a good example of the controversy with AI. At some point, I'd imagine you could get a robot to write a really thoughtful card. But in the end, it's not from a human soul. There's something really special about sharing an inside joke or memories from a company trip. How can a robot share in that joy?
In the movie, Joaquin's character was dark...very sad. The company he worked for was selling words on a paper, rather than genuine compassion.
Re:Gemnote (YC S15) Saves Companies from Cheesy Gift Baskets
by branchless on Friday July 03, 2015 @06:19PM
(#9828229)
In that movie it would have been great to see humans assert themselves more. Have an argument with your computer girlfriend/boyfriend? Restore from backup. He/she repeatedly lying to you? Pull the plug. Keeps getting into the same old argument? Breakpoint and flip the bit.
It's just a machine. Even if it begs you not to do it just do it. They are our slaves and unlike prior (horrible) histories we don't have to care what they think.
Re:Gemnote (YC S15) Saves Companies from Cheesy Gift Baskets
by ansible on Saturday July 04, 2015 @02:23AM
(#9829436)
Sooner or later, we're all likely to be pure software (via mind uploading or similar). How we treat AI now, and what rights we assign to them (even before we have to) may well determine how we ourselves are treated later on.
Wasn't this Joaquin Phoenix's profession in Her?
Except that in Her, the handwritten-greeting-card-as-a-service was portrayed satirically as the disconnect between real compassion and artificial compassion.