If your argument was that no programmer should be surprised that you can tell an archive utility to execute an arbitrary script, then you and the author of the post are in complete agreement. The remaining difference is that the article actually does something to fix the problem while you merely hurl an implicit insult at anyone who hasn't seen this type of privilege escalation yet. One of these actions is more constructive than the other.
You and I have vastly different opinions on what constitutes privilege escalation.
The parent post's anger and disgust is misplaced, though. This article is informative at a novice level, and well-written to that level. Not a trainwreck.
The problem is that there is a way for untrusted user input to ever touch a shell in the first place.
Seriously, I challenge you to find a language reference that doesn't decry the use of their version of system(3)---because all that does is run the given command under the user's shell.
It's really aggravating to learn something from an article that is making someone more knowledgeable this angry without explanation.
All that said, between Gmail's spam filter, my avoidance of all things bitcoin, and common sense with passwords (don't ever re-use them), most of the damage caused by this doesn't affect me.
I will note, however, that this are why "when you hit return in the URL bar, what actually happens," is a valid interview question, in the same unfortunate sense that FizzBuzz is a valid interview question.
I'm asking you why you thought the knife would stop cutting things when it hit your hand instead of the loaf of bread.
If you give rsync command a source or destination with an unescaped colon, it will read an ENVIRONMENT VARIABLE to figure out a command to run to AUTOMATICALLY CONNECT TO ARBITRARY NETWORK RESOURCES. If you have keys, it will even SKIP PASSWORD ENTRY, and with default Kerberos, it will not only skip password, but make a network connections to a login server:port specified by a DNS ENTRY.
Seriously, who is this guy, and why is this trainwreck #1 on HN?