News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the Dutch oppose windmills by shiggerino on Friday July 03, 2015 @03:30AM (#9824066)
The wind turbine scam is not that much better than the solar roadways scam. It's a huge nuisance, expense and environmental impact for very little power.

The only reasonable choice is nuclear power.

Re:Why the Dutch oppose windmills by jacquesm on Friday July 03, 2015 @04:06AM (#9824210)
Why do you call wind turbines a scam? They work, they produce significant power, are clean and the machines built since 2000 have spectacular reliability.

The expense is lower per KWh produced over the lifetime of the machine than most other sources of power so I'm not sure where your 'huge expense' comes from (yes, they're expensive but you should not look at the up-front expense without looking at the total power produced over the lifetime of the machine multipled by the average price of a KWh over that time and then each and every windmill installed so far except for a very few that broke catastrophically and a lot of lessons were learned from those instances). The environmental impact is mostly in people's heads rather than something measurable (I should know, I have windmills within spitting distance from my house). Nuisance is a term that would require some explanation as well.

And each windmill may make 'little power' (though we now have machines capable of 8MW!), but in the aggregate they produce significant power.

If you feel the only reasonable choice is nuclear power then you've already made up your mind about this but as a windmill proponent I see a place for both, nuclear (pebble bed, not old style rod reactors) or natural gas for baseline, wind and solar for when it's available.

Re:Why the Dutch oppose windmills by shiggerino on Friday July 03, 2015 @04:31AM (#9824307)
8MW sounds nice, but a nuclear power plant will easily have 4 orders of magnitude more power output for the same visual impact, and that's around the clock, whether the wind blows or not.

I wouldn't dismiss rod reactors outright, but developing new technology to improve safety and fuel efficiency should of course be a priority. Especially since weapons plutonium production isn't a priority as it was when conventional reactors were designed.

Re:Why the Dutch oppose windmills by jerven on Friday July 03, 2015 @06:22AM (#9824629)
The real problem is that the nuclear power plant will easily have 5 orders of magnitude construction costs associated with it. And historically a 10 times longer construction period. i.e. you have 7 years no power then a 1 GW is added to the grid with nuclear. While wind parks are much more gradual in rolling into production.

This more modular approach to current wind power is also why wind parks tend to end at 300MW nameplant capacity. If you need more power its better to have more tenders for WEPs and benefit from improved technology and economics for the next phase.

Nuclear could be modular and cheap but currently you can't buy modular and cheap nuclear solutions if you wanted too. So you end up with multi year areva construction solutions.

Nuclear power with its current large plants is not easy on the grid either. In the UK wind was really helped because all the pumped storage build to make the 60&70's nuclear fleet cost effective.

Re:Why the Dutch oppose windmills by jacquesm on Friday July 03, 2015 @04:45AM (#9824346)
Yes, nuclear power plants are bigger.

But so what, many windmills equate a nuclear power plant in generating capacity (but as you correctly state not in baseline generating capacity, windmills have 0 of that).

The visual impact of a windmill is a different category than the visual impact of a nuclear power plant, it is more distributed so affects more people, on the other hand, some people actually like the windmills.

Just windmills or just nuclear power is short sighted, there is an optimum mixture of both renewables and other sources of power.

Re:Why the Dutch oppose windmills by wobbleblob on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:29AM (#9825441)
Nuclear power is politically not feasible right now. People who don't want to see windmills are not going to be OK with cooling towers on the horizon either. An irrational fear of the word nuclear is one of the few things that unites left and right, the environmentally conscious and the fossil fuel lobby, the debate on this is pretty much over for the next few generations.

Windmills alone cannot meet the total energy need of the Dutch economy, but the neat thing about windmills is that you could potentially plant them almost anywhere in the landscape, without them getting in the way, so it's a nice way to use land that's otherwise being wasted, like dikes, road sides, polders etc.

Re:Why the Dutch oppose windmills by masklinn on Friday July 03, 2015 @04:34AM (#9824314)
> And each windmill may make 'little power' (though we now have machines capable of 8MW!), but in the aggregate they produce significant power.

Sway and AMSC have 10MW turbines (respectively ST10 and SeaTitan)

Still, you've got to compare that with a modern nuclear reactor producing ~1400MWe, and account for nuclear plants having multiple reactors. While hydro beats all in power per plant you still need quite a lot of turbines to produce as much as a nuke (especially when you account for wind variations, so you generally need to overbuild on wind capacity to get the same annual generation).

Alta in Kern County (California) has 440 turbines and while its nameplate capacity rivals a single reactor (1360MWe) its capacity factor (ratio of actual production to nameplate capacity) is under 20% that of an average nuclear plant (at about 15%, Alta running at full capacity all year could theoretically produce ~11500 GWh, it effectively produces ~1700GWh; by comparison Palo Verde has a theoretical capacity of 34531GWh and according to wikipedia an effective yearly generation of 29250 GWh, an 85% capacity factor)

Re:Why the Dutch oppose windmills by jacquesm on Friday July 03, 2015 @04:47AM (#9824352)
But those thousands of acres are not covered with windmills, the land is just as arable as it was before. That's the really nice thing about wind power, it uses relatively little area for the power generated. The base of each machine is maybe 10 meters in diameter and usually there is some kind of access path.
Re:Why the Dutch oppose windmills by masklinn on Friday July 03, 2015 @04:55AM (#9824378)
> But those thousands of acres are not covered with windmills, the land is just as arable as it was before.

While that is very much true, you still need 20~25 times more surface area to get an equivalent effective production to a nuclear plant, so you need to have all that area available in the first place. And the original land may not be arable at all.

(I'm very much in favour of more wind power, I'm just sad so many people run scared of nuclear base production. Hopefully SMRs will eventually improve that situation though I'm not holding my breath)

Re:Why the Dutch oppose windmills by masklinn on Friday July 03, 2015 @03:44AM (#9824121)
Nuclear has great power density and is a much better option than gas or coal as far as I'm concerned, but it remains a temporary patch, it is not a renewable resource.

And it's not like a nuclear plant is cheap (oh boy is it not), nuisance-free (you can still use an onshore windfarm's land for e.g. pasture) or without environmental impact (ignoring seashore nukes which have their own extra risks, rivershore plants need regulation to avoid overheating downriver and they make the land they're on unusable long after their removal, and obviously because of the amount of cooling the average-sized nuclear plant requires you can't just plop them anywhere you want).

SMRs might be an improvement to some of the drawbacks, but they don't currently exist and we don't have >half a century of experience with them and they're not quite maintenance free (most designs seem to plan refueling every 1 to 5 years). Also "small" is relative, though it helps that you can partially bury the assembly.

Re:Why the Dutch oppose windmills by JoeAltmaier on Friday July 03, 2015 @09:05AM (#9825299)
I disagree with all that. Having millennia of Thorium available is essentially renewable, at least for this civilization. The cost history of nuclear could change completely with new reactors that don't suffer from meltdown etc. Nuclear can definitely be nuisance-free- build in underground silos where they're needed, and not serviced for decades. The existing windmills were fiction a decade ago. Its all in where you put the development money.
Re:Why the Dutch oppose windmills by dev-da0 on Friday July 03, 2015 @04:19AM (#9824259)
Strawman fallacy without evidence and denial of pragmatic holistic mix of power generation sources. There is no perfect panacea power generation; each has its tradeoffs. Solar, geothermal, heat pump, tidal (sea life compatible, not underwater "windmills") and fission molten salt are all mostly good AFAWN. I personally don't like wind generators near bird and bat migratory and feeding paths, but I'm sure someone will develop solutions to prevent needless animal strike events. Deploying BWR/PWR plants as are currently designed is economic and community suicide (Fukahshima)... Taylor Smith's TED talk is actually quite brilliant on where practical fission needs to go (low pressure, higher temp, molten salt with scram basin underneath). Disclaimer: I used to work in the energy industry when nuclear was dying back in the late 1990's.
Re:Why the Dutch oppose windmills by jacquesm on Friday July 03, 2015 @04:37AM (#9824327)
The bird strike issue seems to me to be vastly exaggerated, windmills are positioned as bird butchering machines with vast numbers of corpses lining their circumference.

In practice it rarely happens, I have windmills (large ones and smaller ones in significant numbers) within spitting distance from my house which also sits in the middle of one of the largest bird breeding grounds in the country. I have spent quite a bit of time at the base of the machines to look for evidence of birdstrikes but I haven't found more bird remains near the windmills than near other man made structures.

Of course I'm only one guy which happens to like rewewable energy technology so don't take my word for this.

There are some studies about this:

http://www.livescience.com/41644-wind-energy-threat-to-birds...

If anything my attempt at evidence collection indicates that the larger machines (which have a much larger swept area than the smaller ones) fare better in this respect because the rotors turn much more slowly, but the tips are still moving at very high speed (200 KM/h) and that's where the danger lies. Smaller machines rotate much faster and the whole disc area is a bad place for a bird to be.

Even so, anything we make (buildings, highways, windmills) affects wildlife and birds are killed by all of the above with the primary killer being the highways and the secondary one the buildings. Windmills do kill birds but they're a distant third.

Re:Why the Dutch oppose windmills by mdemare on Friday July 03, 2015 @06:03AM (#9824587)
I remember reading that Dutch windmills kill 30K birds per year. Dutch cats kill 30 million birds.
Re:Why the Dutch oppose windmills by gbtw on Friday July 03, 2015 @04:42AM (#9824342)
With evolution, if this really was a problem, it would not be one in a few generations :)
Re:Why the Dutch oppose windmills by Altay- on Friday July 03, 2015 @07:16AM (#9824784)
Reasonable how? Nuclear power is insanely expensive and no private investor would fund a nuclear project without a myriad of government assistance in the form of insurance guarantees, subsidized loans, etc.

The time horizon for a nuclear plant alone makes them inconceivable as anything but government white elephant projects...

Re:Why the Dutch oppose windmills by sjtrny on Friday July 03, 2015 @04:05AM (#9824207)
Yeh they are such a nuisance. What with being located on farms or out at sea with no one around.

Get a grip.

Re:Why the Dutch oppose windmills by shiggerino on Friday July 03, 2015 @04:10AM (#9824231)
Pro tip: there are people both on farms and at sea.

Also birds and bats that collide with the blades, many of which are endangered.

Re:Why the Dutch oppose windmills by Tomte on Friday July 03, 2015 @04:43AM (#9824344)
That's just not true.

Collision with the blades rarely happens. Birds usually collide with the tower itself, because they get disturbed and try to flee. Towards the sky, which their evolutional programming has identified as "the light".

That's why lots of wind turbines today are painted in different shades of green and brown on the lower part of the tower.