I find MG fantastic, but sometimes his articles and books lack depth. He is a wonderful writer and populariser, but I wonder whose side I would take if this were a real debate.
But it isn't. There's room for both opinions. I've never met Gardner and am now unlikely to do so, but I know a few people who know him fairly well. I'll ask their opinion when I get the chance.
Do you have a reference for that review?
http://www.cs.nyu.edu/pipermail/fom/1997-November/000128.htm...
http://books.google.com/books?id=oXEaTdstD7gC&pg=PA280&#...
I did not find it scathing, but rather of mixed opinions. He criticizes the sort of mathematical "cultural relativism" that the authors sometimes suggest, but he also praises the book's treatment of specific topics as accessible and inspiring.
Thanks for noting this review, because this book is one I like and often recommend to less-technical people, and I had never encountered it before.
Don't be scared by the fact that it is a book. It is very accessible since it is divided into little articles on different areas of math. A lay person can read it and gain a sense of what this math stuff is and how varied it is. A PhD can read the same material and will appreciate it on a much deeper level.
Let me give one data point. I know more mathematicians who became interested in math because of reading The Mathematical Experience than any other book. Seriously.