News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by badsock on Thursday July 02, 2015 @12:47PM (#9820053)
I make enough money that any swing to the left generally costs me more than I gain from it. I don't vote that way because of narrow self-interest, I do it because I want a better society to live in, and the majority of the hard data I've seen says that a redistributive system results in a better society.
Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by rebootthesystem on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:23PM (#9821748)
I think the mistake you are making is to equate the left or left-leaning policies with with a better society.

Comparing to other countries and looking at a ranking system in Wikipedia is also a mistake. We are not the same. You are not comparing the same things. There are societal, cultural and historical differences that have a huge impact on the results of any given policy. Also, our economy is much, much larger and diverse, in absolute terms, than that of most countries.

The Nordic countries tend to be used as a model to support distributive socialist positions. The problem is that you just can't draw parallels between these nations and the US. Our system, our people, our politicians, our industry, our geography our social construct is very different from theirs.

Here's an interesting paper from MIT discussing some of their challenges:

http://economics.mit.edu/files/5726

Here's an excerpt:

"The two phenomena taken together imply a tendency for total spending on welfare services to rise faster than GDP over time. As long as the production of these services remains in the public domain, or as long as they are tax-financed, the tax burden must also exhibit a tendency to rise continuously with GDP. This is a problem of the welfare state that we have been living with for decades now. However, starting from an already high tax burden, the efficiency cost of further increases in tax wedges will at some stage rise steeply, and high taxes will eventually cause serious harm to employment and growth. It seems to us that we may be close to a critical point where the deadweight losses due to high tax wedges and, particularly, their effect on labour force participation rates start to bite seriously. This is particularly so in view of some of the consequences of globalization and demographic change."

And that's the problem. You can make it work for a while in some societies, but it is not a sustainable long-term model. Greece being a bad example of this.

An almost trivial exercise using Excel can easily demonstrate how flawed these ideas tend to be.

The Nordic countries can, to a large extent, live the way they live thanks to a lot of what has come out of "the west". Look around your home or office. All of what you see is the result of capitalism at work. From your clothes to your furniture, watch, phone, computer, car, etc. The life saving devices the Nordic countries use to treat their population would not have existed had the entire world operated as they do. They are all the result of capitalism. In other words, socialist societies, could be argued, have been able to keep the status quo thanks to capitalism.

That's one view. The other is purely mathematical (the Excel spreadsheet model).

I find that anyone who's run a non-trivial business for many years eventually gains an understanding that seems impossible to get as an employee or as a government worker. When you run a business you very quickly understand that income distribution is a formula for disaster. It is not sustainable and it does not, despite how it is being sold by the left, result in a better society.

If you want a better society to live in you owe it to yourself to truly and objectively look at what the welfare state has done to our country. The war on poverty is decades old and our poor as more miserable than ever. The war on education, same thing. All of these government programs create more misery than wealth.

Look at the contrast between a SpaceX and traditional aerospace contractors. Amazing! And, frankly, you don't get the full sense of the difference until you actually walk through SpaceX --as I have-- and see how different things are when compared to traditional government contractors. It's almost the difference between being motivated and being brain-dead.

If you want a better society then you should want more freedom, more entrepreneurship, more SpaceX's and less of anything that has to do with the government controlling your life and your business. We want them to manage our country, maintain roads, enforce reasonable laws and regulations and create solid and productive relationships with other countries. If you truly want a better society you ought to demand results, efficiency, compassion, fairness, frugality, stability and a whole host of things out of our government that we have not had for over 50 years, regardless of which party has been in power.

To be sure, the topic is complex, perhaps well beyond our comprehension. All I can ask is that you don't form your opinion based on what they tell you and a single world view. Look at what they have actually accomplished. I am not a Reagan fan-boy but the question he asked in a debate way-back-when is powerful and should be applied to any ideology from any party: Are you better off today than you were <insert date>. Look at Democrat and Republican promises and ideology and see what they've accomplished after decades and decades of being in power. Are poor people really better off today than fifty years ago due to government programs or due to progress created by a mostly free capitalist society. I think the answer is obvious, just remove everything they have and can do today that is a result of capitalism and you have the USSR.

Just think. Don't follow. Lead.

Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by badsock on Thursday July 02, 2015 @10:14PM (#9823008)
Your opening argument precludes a huge amount of critical empirical information. Comparing how policies work out in other countries isn't perfect, but it's the only way to know anything about how they operate in the real world other than actually implementing the policy in your own country. And that's a chicken-and-egg thing, because why would you try a different policy direction if there's no evidence that it works?

I understand the impulse behind American Exceptionalism, but it looks to me like a recipe for gridlocked ideology, because instead of evidence from other countries, one can only argue using abstract theories...

...which is what I'd categorize most of the rest of your post. All the excel spreadsheets and econ papers in the world aren't going to hold sway with me against the significant numerical evidence that if you're anything but rich in the US, you're probably better off in a number of other countries. Yes of course there are meaningful differences between countries, but leisure hours, bankruptcies due to medical reasons, violent crime rates - these and many more are very universal and can be compared.

Furthermore, even if the US is incomparable, most other countries (for example New Zealand or Canada) are much more similar to Norway than the US, and should be following policies that have been successful for the later, not the former.

In terms of the failed social policies of the US and Greece, I would put that down to poor governance. Better designed policies in the same vein have succeeded, demonstrably, in other countries.

So while I appreciate the time you've taken to write your post, there's nothing in it that lends weight to your argument that leftist policies result in a worse place. The US, even the Democrats, are right of centre. If things were better in Reagan's past, you can't pin it on leftism. Since his time, they've reduced business taxes, reduced progressive taxation, and failed to implement leftist programs like universal healthcare. Yes, things are worse for the median American - this is what the left predicted. Things have gotten better for the average Swede in the same time period.

Of course, you seem to be arguing that governments in general make things worse the more that they are involved. But it's very easy to come up with an imaginary system of governance that is better than the status quo. That's what Marx did. It's a completely different thing to see it work in practice, and if you've got an example of a functioning society where the averge person doesn't suffer for the lack of environmental, labour, etc. regulations, and from the lack of universal education and healthcare, I would love to see it.

Finally, that "Just think. Don't follow. Lead." line. I know you mean it to be inspiring, but implying that I hold these opinions because I haven't considered them deeply, or that I've been brainwashed, just isn't productive.

Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by oldmanjay on Thursday July 02, 2015 @12:57PM (#9820118)
The USSR notwithstanding. Or whatever it is China does.
Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by badsock on Thursday July 02, 2015 @01:29PM (#9820313)
This is basically the mirror argument of the "if you like libertarianism so much, why don't you move to Somalia?" argument that didgeoridoo rightly calls out in this thread.

You don't have to be a Marxist to point out that often where there's well-funded, universally accessible mental health and addiction treatment programs crime has dropped significantly, for instance.

Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by oldmanjay on Thursday July 02, 2015 @01:53PM (#9820476)
I'm not arguing against social programs. I'm noting the fact that the grandest experiment in redistribution to date resulted in massive amounts of human misery.
Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by pavel_lishin on Thursday July 02, 2015 @01:56PM (#9820497)
And being clever science-minded individuals, we can learn from that particular experiment and avoid some of its more egregious mistakes.
Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by oldmanjay on Thursday July 02, 2015 @01:59PM (#9820509)
Absolutely! And as clever science-minded individuals, it's important that we DO learn from it before praising the all-powerful curative nature of wealth redistribution just because it feels good.
Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by badsock on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:19PM (#9820619)
You're both arguing against a straw man (no one in this thread has even hinted that wealth redistribution is an "all-powerful curative"), and belittling people by implying that their reasoning is based on what "feels good" rather than logic and empiricism.

It would make HN better if you tried to make more substantive arguments for your position.

Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by oldmanjay on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:34PM (#9820710)
What you responded to isn't even an argument, it's an agreement.

If you feel belittled then that is on you. I have no particular obligation to ensure that you feel good about your position.

Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by badsock on Thursday July 02, 2015 @03:58PM (#9821227)
If you genuinely believe that you are in agreement, I think you missed pavel_lishin's point.

And while it's true you have no obligation towards my feelings, you have obligation to the quality of discussion here on HN. You have to act like those with differing opinions might have arrived at them through a lot of thought and study, not just by being overly-emotional and ignorant of economics.

Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by briandear on Thursday July 02, 2015 @01:21PM (#9820264)
Redistribution results in one thing: equal levels of misery. Re: Cuba, Venenzuela, pre-Deng Xiaoping China, the Warsaw Pact countries, Vietnam. Standards of living are higher in capitalist countries, that's a fact. Aside from the insane, nobody in 1987 said, "Citizenship in the USSR would be so much I nicer than here in the U.S." Also interesting: the lines around US consulates to get immigrant visas-- they often extend around the block. Every single day. The line outside the Cuban embassy? None. If a redistributive economy is best, why aren't Latin Americans sneaking into Cuba instead of into the United States? Why aren't the Hondurans making the trip to Venenzuela instead of risking the danger of crossing through Mexico to get to the United States? I would offer that the poorest people in the world all want to go to the U.S. Not because of redistributive policies, but because of opportunity. You can't become rich in Cuba. You can't even start a business of any consequence there. You can't get capital loans. what's the incentive to innovate and work hard if the government is just going to steal your efforts. The government should have a regressive tax;bathe current tax system actually penalizes success and rewards failure.
Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by badsock on Thursday July 02, 2015 @01:52PM (#9820465)
I don't get how some people seem to think that there's only two possible political systems in the world.

When I say redistributive, I mean things like progressive taxation, estate taxes, and basic income. In terms of median household income, the US places 6th in the world (and dropping), behind 5 countries whose taxation systems are significantly more progressive, so I dispute your claim of "equal levels of misery":

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Median_household_income

I really do understand that incentives matter, and that progressive taxation is also progressively disincentivizing. However, the countries in the world that have a better quality of life for the majority of their people are to the left of America, not to the right. And I'm more swayed by data than abstract economic theories.

Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by lotharbot on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:12PM (#9820590)
since your argument is about the effect of taxes, "median household income ... before deduction of taxes" (which is what the wikipedia page shows) isn't really a useful metric.
Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by badsock on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:31PM (#9820692)
You are 100% correct, thanks! Here's a more appropriate link:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_net_take-...

The US is 7th, behind a very similar group of steep-progressive-tax countries.

I would say an even better metric is median quality of life indicators (which tell a similar story of the US trailing left-wing countries) but that's an understandably more controversial index.

Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by lotharbot on Thursday July 02, 2015 @03:10PM (#9820953)
A further nitpick: pretty much any index of this sort (particularly QoL) also has to be corrected for demographic trends -- the US absorbs around 20% of the world's total immigrant population [0], and the majority come from much poorer countries (#33 Mexico, not-even-ranked China, India, Philippines, Vietnam, El Salvador, etc. [1]) Those are countries with much worse economies, health care outcomes, education systems, etc. -- all of which have significant effects on both "median" and "average" numbers for measures of the US as a whole.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_immigrant...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_to_the_United_Stat...

Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by badsock on Thursday July 02, 2015 @04:42PM (#9821489)
13% of the population of the US is immigrants; for Sweden it's 14%, and Norway it's 13% (source: Wikipedia).
Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by lotharbot on Friday July 03, 2015 @04:51PM (#9827893)
Sweden gets around 10% of its immigrants [0] from Finland, which is nearly tied with it in the net take-home pay list above. Sweden gets an additional >10% of its immigrants from countries above it in the net take-home pay list, or more than 20% total from top-20 countries.

The US, on the other hand, gets the vast majority of its immigrants from much poorer countries [1]. The US gets around 7% of its immigrants from top-20 countries.

Particularly when it comes to median statistics, adding people at the bottom of the scale is going to skew the stats.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_to_Sweden#Country_...

[1] http://cis.org/2012-profile-of-americas-foreign-born-populat...

Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by badsock on Friday July 03, 2015 @11:16PM (#9829001)
Thanks for the data! From the same site as your second link:

http://cis.org/node/3877

If you look at table 29, immigrants make 93% as much income as natives nation-wide. Given that they account for only 13% of the population, that means that they represent less than a percent of income reduction nation-wide. Admittedly I'm talking mean not median here, but I'm not buying the argument that a regular person in the most powerful economy on the planet is having a harder time than the ones in the tiny countries of Australia, Belgium, and Germany because of a 1% drag on national income.

Americans have forgone universal health care, a strong social safety net, free or cheap higher education, all in the pursuit of a better economy and higher personal incomes. Lots of leftist countries haven't had to make that sacrifice, and yet even if you added 1% to the per capita income of Americans, they'd still be at least in the same ballpark, if not still ahead. From where I stand, that was not a good trade.

Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by lotharbot on Saturday July 04, 2015 @02:20PM (#9831036)
> "I'm not buying the argument that a regular person in the most powerful economy on the planet is having a harder time than the ones in the tiny countries ... because of a 1% drag"

... that's OK, since I never made that argument.

What I'm arguing is simply that statistics that don't correct for population/immigration trends aren't going to give you a complete picture. You're not comparing directly comparable situations.

> "Americans have forgone universal health care, a strong social safety net, free or cheap higher education, all in the pursuit of a better economy and higher personal incomes."

Americans have foregone those things, opting for crappier, more expensive, and less universal variants of those things, mostly in the name of refusing to compromise while actually compromising in entirely moronic ways. There is no sense in which the government has done a good job of crafting programs to be efficient and therefore to improve the economy or personal incomes. (Personally, I'm a fan of the "basic income" as the foundation for a strong safety net, as well as more efficient systems of education overall. It's in one sense more extreme and in another sense less extreme than what's common in Europe. But we'll never get it because everyone would rather play political football and end up with compromise solutions that are the worst of both worlds.)

[EDIT: going out of town for a week. You may have the last word if you so desire.]

Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by badsock on Saturday July 04, 2015 @07:39PM (#9831943)
That works out OK, because I don't disagree with anything you just said :) If it's a vacation you're leaving for, have a good one!
Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by paulhauggis on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:24PM (#9820653)
"behind 5 countries whose taxation systems are significantly more progressive, so I dispute your claim of "equal levels of misery":"

Maybe not equal levels of misery, but significantly less purchasing power (In Australia for instance, a small bag of chips and a 20 oz. of coke is $11 at the local 7-11 when I was there last year), less innovation, and less freedom beyond a corporate 9-5.

When it takes a court case to fire an employee and taxes and restrictions are that large, how can 3 people in a dorm room possibly build a successful company? It's also pretty telling when venture capitalists pretty much avoid any of those countries.

Here are average wages in Sweden for instance (2012):

http://lostinstockholm.com/2012/01/10/average-salaries-in-sw...

"estate tax and basic income"

Everything you mentioned are just schemes for redistributing wealth. It's exactly what the op said they don't want.

If I work my entire life to build my fortunes, why should the government get a large percentage before my family? I see it no different than theft.

Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by badsock on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:52PM (#9820819)
I dispute your purchasing power argument:

http://www.statista.com/statistics/226956/average-world-wage...

You'll note that Austria and Norway beat the US, and Sweden and Finland are in the ballpark.

I'm not arguing about innovation or "freedom", I'm arguing about a better society - one with less crime, better social mobility, etc. - for the average person. Not the Internet startup lotto winner.

And the government doesn't "get" a large percentage of your income - they don't keep any of it. Your fellow citizens get it. It goes to pay for the huge amount of infrastructure that you used while amassing your fortune (court system, transporation system, an educated healthy population to draw employees from, etc.).

You view taxation as theft. I view people who use infrastructure and then don't want to contribute back as welchers.

Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by paulhauggis on Thursday July 02, 2015 @03:43PM (#9821141)
"I'm arguing about a better society - one with less crime, better social mobility, etc."

Those countries have less crime because they are very strict on immigration. Many people come to the US and instead of creating a new life and a new culture, keep the broken culture from the county they left, and in many cases, means an increase in crime.

It's also easier to maintain because those countries have as many people as a large city in the US..so the comparison isn't really fair.

"It goes to pay for the huge amount of infrastructure that you used while amassing your fortune (court system, transporation system, an educated healthy population to draw employees from, etc.)."

Those are already paid through many other taxes, so this isn't really a valid reason. Most people that are wealthy already paid many more in taxes than they will ever use. Where did all that money go?

"You view taxation as theft. I view people who use infrastructure and then don't want to contribute back as welchers."

I view an estate tax as theft, not taxes in general. Stop putting words in my mouth to fit your agenda. Let me guess: You are in your early-mid 20s and don't have a lot of wealth?

I run 2 very successful businesses and pay way more money in taxes than most people make in a year...and will continue to pay more in taxes than I will ever take from the system.

We also don't really have any government accountability. If we could actually track where our money was going, there might not be all of this need to take more.

"better social mobility"

How do you think we achieve social mobility? One of the best ways is to start a company. You don't even need an education. In the US, you can pay less than $50 in most states to make your company official..or even just run it under your own name as a sole-proprietorship.

In all of the countries you mention, there is virtually no social mobility and pretty much the only place to get a job is either at a large corporation or for the government.

And lastly, I just don't trust the government to manage my tax money that well.

Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by badsock on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:47PM (#9822251)
I don't think you can blame immigrants as the deciding factor in crime. To quote Wikipedia: "In the US, studies have found lower crime rates among immigrants than among non-immigrants" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_and_crime). Furthermore, as I mentioned elsewhere in the thread, the US doesn't have a higher immigrant population than other places such as Sweden and Norway with much lower crime. And finally, immigrants are only 13% of the US population, so there would have to be a very large difference in criminality to move the needle in the overall population.

Sorry for misinterpreting your comment about taxes, I read it too broadly. The reasoning behind estate taxes isn't theft, it was an effort by the US founding fathers to try and stop a hereditary aristocracy from taking hold in America, the way it had in Europe. Inherited wealth is directly opposed to the principles of meritocracy that they held high.

And no, I am not in my 20s. And I too have years of business experience. And I've paid a lot in taxes. I'm genuinely arguing from the perspective of wanting a better society, not how much I can personally acquire.

In terms of social mobility, the data directly contradicts you:

http://www.theguardian.com/business/2010/mar/10/oecd-uk-wors... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Social_mobility_is_lower_... (from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_mobility)

The US has a strong culture of valuing social mobility (pull yourself up by your own bootstraps), but it's not the case in practice.

And finally, the reason that I believe in progressive taxation isn't based on what's more fair or not to the individual taxpayer. I agree that it's not a good feeling to watch your tax rate go up in response to success. But societies that don't engage in redistributive practices in that vein empirically end up in a worse spot across the board (economically and socially). I'd rather live in a better country than one that has a flat tax for ideological reasons. If I'm presented with an example of a society running well with a flat tax, I'd probably change my mind, as (all things being equal) it is much simpler and less unfair.

Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by paulhauggis on Friday July 03, 2015 @05:08PM (#9827960)
"I don't think you can blame immigrants as the deciding factor in crime"

I'm not blaming immigrants. At this point, we have 2nd and 3rd generations of citizens that have not integrated into US culture and continue to keep their own. You don't see this in countries like Sweden, Denmark, or Finland for instance.

When you do, things like this happens:

http://unitedwithisrael.org/it-was-like-a-war-zone-muslims-r...

I'm blaming people with broken cultures and views that don't integrate into their host country. Abandoning broken cultures is a good thing as it helps us progress as a society. We are so politically correct in the US, broken cultures are not only allowed to survive, but thrive.

"I'm genuinely arguing from the perspective of wanting a better society,"

We have a great society now. Of course it's not perfect and could use some changes. However, limiting successful people and encouraging people to not work is not the answer.

The ability to succeed has been what's made us great in the first place. We should be encouraging and rewarding success and making it easier for the average person to start and build a company, not harder.

"in terms of social mobility, the data directly contradicts you:"

You have:

-High taxes (When added up, Sweden is close to 70%..which is on par with Denmark, Finland, Norway, and France) -The inability for the average person to start a company because of government restrictions -A lack of investors -Culture norms like Jante law (which looks down upon people achieving success..a requirement for social mobility): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_Jante

With all of this said, there can't possibly be that much social mobility. It limits the success of anyone that truly wants to improve their lifestyle and redistributes their wealth to everyone, even if they don't contribute anything to society for the better. This isn't the same as social mobility.

The US has great social mobility. If you are willing to put the time and effort, you can go from poor, to middle class, and even rich. You don't even have to have an education. The possibilities are endless.

In countries like Sweden, your possibilities are limited severely, but the amount of free money you get from the government is much more. So, you pretty much end up with one class of people. Both low and upper classes converge toward the middle.

The average wages show this in practice:

http://lostinstockholm.com/2012/01/10/average-salaries-in-sw...

All successful companies (IKEA is a good example of this) (and even many singers) leave Sweden because of these harsh restrictions.

"The US has a strong culture of valuing social mobility (pull yourself up by your own bootstraps), but it's not the case in practice."

It's not the case now because so many people aren't willing to put the work into it. All of the successful people that I know worked nights, days, and weekends for years. The majority of people just aren't willing to put the effort to succeed. They want to party during college, have fun on the weekends, and hang out with their friends or watch TV at night. This is fine, but you can't expect to get ahead in any career unless you sacrifice.

"I agree that it's not a good feeling to watch your tax rate go up in response to success. But societies that don't engage in redistributive practices in that vein empirically end up in a worse spot across the board (economically and socially)"

I disagree. Everyone talks about how bad the US is, yet we have millions of immigrants begging to get in every year and are still the most powerful country in the world.

This isn't by luck. It's because of the economic system currently in place and the ability for anyone to succeed.

Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by badsock on Friday July 03, 2015 @10:44PM (#9828923)
I'm not saying this to be deliberately combative, but when you say things like "With all of this said, there can't possibly be that much social mobility." you're favouring a theoretical model over actual reality.

The data in the links I posted say, unambigiously, that if you're born in a poor family in the US, you are more likely to stay poor than someone who is born in poverty in Sweden. That's not a theory, that's what the data says; and it's not controversial data - all they have to do is look at your income tax records and then your parents to see if you've escaped poverty.

You make an argument about the amount of regulation, the disincentivizing force of taxes, the lack of investment, the difficulty in starting new companies. Sure, I can see how that makes sense as a concept. But the concept is clearly flawed, because if you look at the black and white numbers (as opposed to what you've observed anecdotally) it doesn't reflect what's actually happened on the ground.

Despite the high taxes, despite all of the companies that are apparently fleeing the country, despite all of the regulations, poor Swedes with gumption and drive actually have a better chance at escaping poverty than poor Americans.

There's any number of theories about why that is: it's easier to take chances on starting a company when you know you're not risking homelessness when you fail; very low cost higher education is actually helpful in improving your lot in life; having high quality nutrition and primary education regardless of your parent's income helps poor children do better, etc. But those are just theories - who knows if they're right? They're just possible explanations for how things got to be the way they are.

Bottom line is that Sweden (and many other leftist countries) are doing well at making sure the average person living there is being rewarded according to who they are and not who their parents are. The US, though it has many impressive qualities, and though people talk a lot about hard work being rewarded, isn't doing as well.

In terms of your link about immigration, "tens of people" rioting is not the kind of numbers that people should look at when deciding policy. Riots involving thousands of people often happen over sports, yet there's no call for legislation around that. Also, an article describing problems that muslims cause from a site called "United With Isreal" is clearly not a good source of unbiased opinion on the matter.

Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by mahyarm on Thursday July 02, 2015 @02:09PM (#9820571)
The USA is very redistributive, but is less efficient in doing so in many ways than other countries.

For example the health care system in america is significantly less economically efficient then the health care system of Canada, which causes a lot of human misery in the USA.

To 'redistribute' wealth, you don't have to directly take money in the form of taxes and directly give it to others. You can also redistribute wealth with 2nd order effects such as rent control, or limiting the supply of doctors through unrelated expensive requirements and so on. Much of the economic inefficiency in the US's health care system comes from these 2nd order policies.

So am I leftist if I want the US to adopt single payer health care and to cut a lot of it's negative 2nd order policies? Or am I conservative/libertarian for wanting it?

Re:What Happens When a State Is Run by Movie Stars? by notahacker on Thursday July 02, 2015 @01:56PM (#9820488)
And redistributive Northern Europe is more miserable than non-redistributive sub-Saharan Africa?

(Actually, on the subject of redistribution in notionally communist countries, it's pretty funny when you're sat round a beer stall in Saigon and its the citizens of the Socialist Republic of Vietnam that are loudly condemning the amount of money that gets redistributed to the indolent poor in the US because the biggest handout most of their own unemployed ever get is a 10% cut on any state lottery tickets they can sell...)