Re:A Quick Puzzle to Test Your Problem Solving
by Verdex on Thursday July 02, 2015 @03:41PM
(#9821122)
Similar story here. I got it in zero because this problem shows up at the early part of HPMOR.
I suspect that the basic idea behind it is about right (people who insist on failures before committing to a theory will probably do "better"). But it seems to me that this test will be best at selecting people who've seen it before and can pretend they didn't (or even remember to ask negative questions when someone asks you to guess three numbers to get the job).
Re:A Quick Puzzle to Test Your Problem Solving
by MichaelDickens on Thursday July 02, 2015 @07:24PM
(#9822410)
Yeah, I'd like to see other sorts of questions that you can only get right by looking for disconfirming evidence, but that don't have anything to do with choosing a sequence of numbers.
It's probably not "fair" to say I got it in zero... but I did. :)
Now that the NYT has done it, this puzzle has probably attained enough popularity now that you really ought to change it up a bit now if you're going to run it yourself. Granted, the space of hypotheses as simple as "increasing/decreasing" is pretty small, but your ability to fool people with the first sample run is almost unbounded, so that helps.