News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Startup That Designed Its Office to Confuse Workers by pjc50 on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:07AM (#9817653)
People have forgotten that attention is transitive: you pay attention to something. If you're paying attention to the environment, what is your attention being diverted from?
Re:A Startup That Designed Its Office to Confuse Workers by prof_hobart on Thursday July 02, 2015 @07:13AM (#9818119)
I'm in the middle of reading Thinking, Fast And Slow and at least some of the research that he talks about in there suggests that this isn't always how the brain actually works. By forcing people to concentrate on one thing, it can (at least in some circumstances) increase how much they concentrate on other things.

The example he used was the sort of problem where there's a obvious, but wrong, answer to a problem (e.g. "If a bat and ball cost £1.10, and the bat is £1 more than the ball, how much does the ball cost", to which a lot of people instinctively answer 10p - using what he refers to as "System 1 thinking"). These sorts of question were presented to two groups of people, one with the questions clearly printed and one with the questions badly printed in very light colours, requiring the readers to concentrate to be able to even read the questions.

The surprising result was that people in the latter group did significantly better on average than those in the former, suggesting that because they are forced to start using the more conscious, and more conscientious, "System 2 thinking" to be able to read the questions, they are primed to use that sort of thinking on actually answering the question.

This isn't always true though - if you're already concentrating heavily on something, then introducing another problem that requires a lot of concentration, you will stop concentrating on the first issue.

So, introducing something that forces your brain into a low-level System 2 mindset (such as slightly wonky offices) might be a good way of reducing the number of "obvious but wrong" decisions being made, but wouldn't be a good way of improving problem solving for tasks where people are already concentrating on the problem.

Re:A Startup That Designed Its Office to Confuse Workers by omginternets on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:22AM (#9817944)
My point exactly.

For those unaware, I recommend reading up on "inattentional blindness". Attention is a very valuable resource.

Re:A Startup That Designed Its Office to Confuse Workers by synthmeat on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:38AM (#9817784)
Anecdotally, I have found that my focus welcomes slight distraction, in various forms - tv show I already know by heart, stupid silly shows, instrumental repetitive music, music I'm extremely familiar already...

Basically, when I'm at risk to lose focus from task at hand, this steals it, and it's rather boring compared to what would most likely be highly abstract contemplations, totally new ideas and so on, so your focus returns to original task since immediate alternative provided is dull affair.

It somehow "eats up" part of my nature that nudges me to lose focus. It's maybe analogous to how rain noise gobbles up various distracting sounds.

Re:A Startup That Designed Its Office to Confuse Workers by omginternets on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:25AM (#9817957)
Taking breaks is clearly a good thing, but being externally distracted is not. If you're thinking about where you're going, you're not thinking about how you're going to present your work at the meeting.
Re:A Startup That Designed Its Office to Confuse Workers by pjc50 on Thursday July 02, 2015 @06:13AM (#9817907)
I suppose that's why I'm on HN while waiting for builds.
Re:A Startup That Designed Its Office to Confuse Workers by chaostheory on Thursday July 02, 2015 @05:27AM (#9817730)
I wonder if it's equivalent to the distraction of an open office?