Well... If it were a chainsaw, then there would be no question whatsoever.
As it is, it's the team who has the soldering iron, who wrote the code, who designed and built the prototype, who figured out production against the other guy who is known for having occasionally hidden ties to companies he talks about on his blog, who has thus doubtful journalistic standards and who posted a couple pictures, promoted the device and published stories about how it would change the world, painting himself as an internet visionary turned hardware mogul.
I stay with the guy with the soldering iron on this one.
Interestingly, I also can't see US$ 299 as such a ludicrous price. I doubt an e-paper display is much less expensive than a LCD twice its size and there are devices in this space that cost $299.
That doesn't get them out of the woods legally, but if all TC has is incriminating snippets of email, it does make them more credible than TC.
I can't believe how many are making that assumption. I had been reading TechCrunch for years before the day I saw Arrington post the original hypothesis for the CrunchPad. In fact, I can probably look up my comments on Google encouraging his going forward, and suggesting features. I'm blown away at how off track this has turned out. Unfortunately, if he didn't handle the legal stuff he has to take the turmoil I guess.
Well, no doubt many people are happy to assume that the person holding the soldering iron is automatically the one who is right.
I will make no such assumption; "infinitely" is more than a little strong. ;) All I will say is: What a lose-lose situation.