[1] http://www.theguardian.com/science/2013/aug/29/poverty-menta...
Or conversely, they might just have more incentive to do what it takes to get paid rather than doing a good job. I think work ethics is a better incentive.
Since this is an experiment I doubt anyone reasonable participating in it would leave their work and live only on basic income. So the result is already determined - basic income doesn't change anything.
IMO to test basic income theory, it should be implemented nation-wide for unspecified period of time - with the ability to cancel it at anytime in case of when negative effects significantly outweight positive ones. When it gets cancelled it failed.
That somebody would not "really need that job" because they would be guaranteed a basic income no matter what in a real world scenario.
So having a small sample set in a big city invalidates part of the experience since the situation is very different from what would really happen if everyone had a guaranteed minimal income.
A koan, of sorts, rough-shod and ill-fitted, yet perfectly shaped for the game.
Since the other person, who's not taking part in the study, wont receive a basic income, the person in the study might feel morally required to give up their job potential job to the person who really needs it, which means the results of the study will be inconclusive.
When you go apply for a job, do you find out who else applied, and decide if any of them "need" the job more than you?
Read from the other side, hiring a poor worker is preferable because they'll put up with more abuse, as they don't have much in the way of choice.
[citation needed]
> All else equal, hiring a poor worker is probably perferable to hiring a wealthy one, as the poor worker has more incentives to work really hard.
[citation needed]
So if any of these selected people will try to find a job, they will probably voluntarily "lose" it to somebody to really needs that job. Even without that moral issue, this makes still sense from a business point of view: All else equal, hiring a poor worker is probably perferable to hiring a wealthy one, as the poor worker has more incentives to work really hard.