IMO, Uber may be hoping that once regular cab services are put out of business, Uber can raise the prices. The sustainable long term value prop seems to be ability to call up a cab using mobile app on your phone (request and dispatch portion of regular cab business). Everything else appears to contribute to loss.
I also don't believe time has come for self-driving cars or will be in next 5 years at least. If another technology bust happens before self-driving cars become popular, these projects will go on the shelf if not cancelled (like the pet projects of founders and executives in 2000 dot bomb).
Don't remember the link, but Kalanick was recently quoted about how he'd buy a bunch of Tesla self-driving cars in 2020. Whether it will be Teslas or not, I believe it's clear that their whole strategy is to move to self-driving cars as immediately as feasible.
It's like saying, "whoa, tomato prices have skyrocketed -- I bet grocery stores are making record profits!"
To be sure, there might be some differential advantage, but not enough to justify subsidizing everyone in the hopes they won't jump ship after competition comes in from other brands without these "legacy costs".
Depends a lot on whether Uber themselves are making this happen, or we're looking to Tesla, Google, etc. If self-driving cars are going to happen anyway, then there's an argument from the other direction that permitting Uber has no long-term benefits.
Ignoring other car services, the public would have the option to buy their own self-driving car, but we'll get to the point where the majority won't. You'll be choosing between:
Own car - larger cost, garaging, cleaning, insurance, power, depreciation, fixed format (sedan, van, truck), etc.
Their car - pay per use, or subscription to use as required, hire the type of vehicle you need when you need it.
When the law catches up, insurance companies will have something in place.
When there's a large scale test, production/distribution have to ramp up.
Even if Uber can replace just 1% of their drivers with self-driving cars it would be worthwhile.
In SF.
In many places uber is currently an unsustainable, heavily subsidised operation which would fail in free market conditions, but because of their big stash of VC $$ they are able to survive while eating away at taxi driver market share.
1. Cost of recruiting drivers is relatively high - probably around $50-$100 per driver. This cost is composed of background check (probably $10-20), the ad that got them in the door ($5-10 for that click), the overhead cost of recruiting staff and onboarding staff and 1099 paperwork ($2-$5). Let's be nice and say $50 is the cost. Again, being generous, if the average ride is $20, and Uber takes 20% ($4), that means that each driver needs to perform 13 rides for Uber to make their $$ back. I don't know for sure, but anecdotally most drivers I've ridden with likely exceeded this, so I'd say they are good on this front.
2. In reading the recent CA administrative decision, the main damages were for reimbursement for mileage, at $0.56 per mile. So this means that IF a state were to determine either that (a) drivers are employees or (b) drivers are not employees but some "third-option hybrid" for whom Uber still needs to reimburse miles, this would great eat into their margins and drag profitability down.
Hrm. Instead of working from first principles, we can poke at some data. Zen99 calculates that Uber seems to be spending some $1M/year on Craigslist ads for SF drivers alone [1], and as of the end of last year, they had about 16,000 drivers in SF [2]. Assuming generously that they recruited them all that year, that's about $62 on Craiglist advertising per driver, much higher than your $5-10 estimate.
There are also incentives like an unconditional $500 on your first ride [3]. In NYC, Uber also offers new drivers a free defensive driving class and doctor's examination at their offices [4], because they need those to get on the road. You will not find doctors to do exams for $2-5.
I would guess total driver acquisition cost, including first-trip incentives, is much more likely to be in the $1000-2000 range, at minimum. And we still haven't gotten to long-term subsidies like uberPOOL, which is what I'm really curious about. Even a $10K driver acquisition cost could maybe be sustainable if each driver lasts over a year on average, since it's a one-time cost. But it needs to pay better than taxi wages + cost of car maintenance for the driver, and at least break even for Uber, in the steady state.
[1] https://tryzen99.com/blog_posts/on-demand-is-in-demand
[2] http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2015/01/22/n...
But it is subsidizing a lot of rides right now, for example "Pool" rides where riders get the discount even if they are the only passenger.
Don't get me wrong, taxis in many cities (especially SF) aren't serving the public reasonably. But Uber is only part of that conversation because it's price-competitive with taxis. If we thank them for identifying the problem, and then solve it by regularizing Uber's legal status, will the problem come back in three years once uberX and uberPOOL need to be profitable? Should we instead focus legislative effort on making taxis work?
I certainly don't complain when I get subsidized lunches delivered to me on VC money, but when existing Uber cities are debating regularizing Uber's legal status or just fixing the inefficiencies / problems with the taxi industry that Uber capitalized on, I want to know if Uber's going to be around for the people of that city, at the same effective prices, in 20 years.