Re:U.S. Supreme Court Denies Google's Request to Appeal Orac...
by dragonwriter on Monday June 29, 2015 @07:24PM
(#9801842)
> Google appealed the federal court decision to the Supreme Court
The appeals court decision -- both the district court and the appeals court are federal courts.
> Appeals courts in the United States do not rule on the facts of a particular case
That's not always true; matters of fact can be appealed, and there are different standards of review on appeal for different kinds of fact question, however, appeals courts generally prefer not to reach fact questions, particularly if the appeal was over a question of law and not specifically on the fact question, and appeals courts generally do not answer questions -- particularly fact or mixed fact/law questions -- that have not been addressed by the court below, as is often the case where the appeals court reverses a finding of law of the lower court, which then makes relevant a fact question that the lower court did not answer because it would have been irrelevant under the lower court's view of the law.
The appeals court decision -- both the district court and the appeals court are federal courts.
> Appeals courts in the United States do not rule on the facts of a particular case
That's not always true; matters of fact can be appealed, and there are different standards of review on appeal for different kinds of fact question, however, appeals courts generally prefer not to reach fact questions, particularly if the appeal was over a question of law and not specifically on the fact question, and appeals courts generally do not answer questions -- particularly fact or mixed fact/law questions -- that have not been addressed by the court below, as is often the case where the appeals court reverses a finding of law of the lower court, which then makes relevant a fact question that the lower court did not answer because it would have been irrelevant under the lower court's view of the law.