Re:Linux, IRIX and “Posix Capabilities” (1999)
by cturner on Monday June 29, 2015 @05:11AM
(#9797077)
Your comment raises a solid use-case I hadn't mentioned: unix running underneath a single-user mobile device.
You do need permission systems for that scenario. But they don't have to be in the OS. You could implement them in the application container.
A difficulty with security services being tied to the OS is that you're tied to the featureset of the OS, which tends to have a slow-moving API. Much better to implement security via library, so it can move at the same pace as your application platform.
There are many ways to build a unix. Unix is strong at hardware interaction (drivers, filesystems), IPC, process control. Security models dilute it. This includes chmod-style filesystems permissions in that. It's lots of complexity that delivers little value.
Curious: Stallman built GNU on unix. He's an open guy himself, and had spent a lot of time with MIT systems that didn't implement security in the OS level.
You do need permission systems for that scenario. But they don't have to be in the OS. You could implement them in the application container.
A difficulty with security services being tied to the OS is that you're tied to the featureset of the OS, which tends to have a slow-moving API. Much better to implement security via library, so it can move at the same pace as your application platform.
There are many ways to build a unix. Unix is strong at hardware interaction (drivers, filesystems), IPC, process control. Security models dilute it. This includes chmod-style filesystems permissions in that. It's lots of complexity that delivers little value.
Curious: Stallman built GNU on unix. He's an open guy himself, and had spent a lot of time with MIT systems that didn't implement security in the OS level.