Re:Porting the Unity Editor to Linux: Stuff I Wish We’d Done...
by isaacremuant on Sunday June 28, 2015 @07:23PM
(#9795546)
Interesting answer. You left out that Ubuntu's recent SDK has a strong relation with Qt.
https://developer.ubuntu.com/en/apps/
The "out of place" argument is one I commonly used by Mac and Linux users because they want everything to look native in their OS of choice and disregard dev time (to use a different window framework for each OS) and look in every other OS.
No one can win that argument to favor THEIR own OS look over another.
Qt apps are pretty reliable across platforms and are speedy to develop so that's what should be important instead of getting an impossible native look.
Re:Porting the Unity Editor to Linux: Stuff I Wish We’d Done...
by rhodysurf on Sunday June 28, 2015 @07:16PM
(#9795522)
You can use gtk styling in Qt apps and it looks just like GTK. Also Ubuntu Unity is switching to Qt for unity 8. As for dependencies, there are definitely more Qt apps on linux than just KDE apps.
Re:Porting the Unity Editor to Linux: Stuff I Wish We’d Done...
by seba_dos1 on Sunday June 28, 2015 @08:51PM
(#9795834)
Plus "KDE apps pull a lot of deps" claim is already outdated, as recent releases of KDE Frameworks are highly modularized.
Re:Porting the Unity Editor to Linux: Stuff I Wish We’d Done...
by JupiterMoon on Tuesday June 30, 2015 @07:27AM
(#9804384)
Not sure that this is true on the ground as yet. I guess it will filter from upstream to LTS distributions over the next few years.
Although I don't actually mind as I find that once you've got one KDE app you end up installing more as they are often quite a lot better (for me) than Gnome ones - and disk space is pretty cheap these days anyway.
Since most Qt apps on linux come from the KDE ecosystem, they often pull in a lot of KDE dependancies, which means a lot of extra packages lying around your system, creating clutter, which might bother some people. The relatively heavyweight nature of most Qt apps makes them less appropriate on systems that use just a window manager rather than a full desktop environment.
Sure, a lot of GTK apps pull in a bunch of GNOME dependancies, but there's also a large contingent of GTK apps from the lighter-weight XFCE world that don't.
Outside of linux, Qt has won pretty decisively, mostly because the GTK developers aren't interested in making GTK apps look good on Mac/Windows, so long as they run.