News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Raven Paradox (logic) by immad on Sunday January 13, 2008 @03:27PM (#97949)
I don't get why this logic violates intuition. The proposed solution in the article is fairly obvious and intuitive. Just because two logical statements are equivalent doesn't mean evidence for one gives evidence for the other:

"The origin of the paradox lies in the fact that the statements "all Ravens are black" and "all non-black things are non-ravens" are indeed logically equivalent, while the act of finding a black raven is not at all equivalent to finding a non-black non-raven. Confusion is common when these two notions are thought to be identical."

Re:The Raven Paradox (logic) by jsnx on Sunday January 13, 2008 @04:49PM (#97973)
If two logical statements are equivalent, then yes indeed, evidence that implies one of them (in classical logic) implies the other one. The solution is indeed intuitive but is not formalizable in classical logic.

Classical logic does not, in general, jibe with the intuition: consider the case of the negative antecedent:

http://www.earlham.edu/~peters/courses/log/mat-imp.htm

For example, the statement, "If unicorns have one horn, then I am the Queen of England." is logically true.

Re:The Raven Paradox (logic) by immad on Sunday January 13, 2008 @08:50PM (#98029)
hmm, I see the point. But isn't that just the limitations of classical logic? Just seems like a question of semantics rather than a clash between logic and intuition, but maybe I don't get it
Re:The Raven Paradox (logic) by jsnx on Monday January 14, 2008 @02:13AM (#98102)
It is a clash between classical logic and intuition, which is the point -- it indicates a difficulty with applying classical logic, and encourages us to take up other avenues.
Re:The Raven Paradox (logic) by zoltz on Sunday January 13, 2008 @05:02PM (#97977)
The part of the Wikipedia article you quote has nothing to do with what you quote it for.
Re:The Raven Paradox (logic) by immad on Sunday January 13, 2008 @08:52PM (#98030)
Yep, you are probably correct. The wikipedia quote is more of a restatement of the paradox. But from that I thought my statement inferred.