Computers do this all the time. Simplest example is "cancel" button everywhere.
Therefore, we lack formal way of satisfactorily compare the brain to a Turing Machine.
Information comes to brain via neurons, and those have finite speed, it's not as they had quantum-like properties. Signal in; signal out, with delay and altered magnitude.
I, too, think that the brain is 'a computer'. But the formal definitions of computation we have today require the computer to be left alone for some time between the moment the input is given and the moment the output is due. The brain does not work like that, ergo we lack a formal model of how the brain operates, and thus the definition of 'computable function' -which is based on our model of computation- is less general than what the brain can do.
e.g. We have no proof that the only way neurons communicate with one another is via the synapses.
I fail to capture the difference.
And we don't, and worse, we may not ever have access to these concepts, as Hofstadter and others have argued. It may not be possible to represent the idea of ideas in an idea.
That of which we cannot speak that thereof we must remain silent, or something.
I'm confused... is the counter-argument AGAINST the brain being BEYOND a Turing machine (if I am to interpret your sentence literally)?
Or by this double negative do you actually mean the counter argument is AGAINST the brain being ONLY a Turing machine? (Because that's what the rest of your post sounds like.)
> and the output partly loops back to the input.
So? Turing machines have no issues with feedback loops; what would lead you to think they do?
Instead, it processes information as it comes, this information comes during the processing of previous information and the output partly loops back to the input. Short-circuits everywhere, no clock, etc. I'm unconvinced but I could not refute the argument formally.
Note that this does not contradict the Church-Turing Hypothesis : if you restrict the brain to one input, some processing steps with a pen and paper without arrival of new information, and an output, then it is very possible that the brain can only work out Turing-computable problems.