News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Adieu google by zackattack on Saturday December 05, 2009 @10:33PM (#979089)
I have been noticing a decline in Google's search results, _especially_ for computer-related help. Tons of awful blog posts, from years ago, created for AdSense money.

Why can't Google [surreptitiously?] rank search results by actual relevancy (e.g. clicks & abandons)? And don't tell me because of voting rings: I have seen "voting ring detection" often as a common screening problem for job interviews.

Re:Adieu google by mcav on Saturday December 05, 2009 @11:26PM (#979150)
> Tons of awful blog posts, from years ago,

This. While humanity has uploaded a lot of valuable, worthwhile information online in the past decade, that's just a blip compared to the amount of totally useless junk online. That makes things harder for all search engines. It also will be interesting to see how search engines cope with the internet as the number of websites/pages continues to grow in the next fifty or so years.

Re:Adieu google by jordyhoyt on Sunday December 06, 2009 @06:12AM (#979419)
Sorry for this to get all meta, but what is the meaning of saying "this" at the beginning of a comment? I've seen it elsewhere, sometimes as the entire response. I'm afraid I missed the beginnings of this convention, and it's not intuitive (at least to me).
Re:Adieu google by steerpike on Sunday December 06, 2009 @06:48AM (#979439)
It's a shorthand for 'I totally agree and what was said bears repeating'. I think it originated on fark, but I'm not totally sure.
Re:Adieu google by telemachos on Sunday December 06, 2009 @09:51AM (#979587)
I thought we already had a way to say that: ditto.
Re:Adieu google by carbocation on Sunday December 06, 2009 @12:18PM (#979819)
The original post asked a question: "Why can't Google [surreptitiously?] rank search results by actual relevancy (e.g. clicks & abandons)?"

The respondent felt that the original post contained the answer to its own question. Therefore, the respondent said, "This," pointing to the answer.

Re:Adieu google by jordyhoyt on Monday December 07, 2009 @01:58AM (#980855)
Ok, I see now that the original poster was effectively saying "this is why", not necessarily using the "this" meme that I was confused about. Still, I got my answer and the post has been clarified for me. Thanks, guys.
Re:Adieu google by jamesbritt on Monday December 07, 2009 @03:07AM (#980900)
" Therefore, the respondent said, "This," pointing to the answer."

Shouldn't it then be "that", or have the quote come after "this"?

Re:Adieu google by NathanKP on Saturday December 05, 2009 @11:49PM (#979180)
Eventually I suppose that we will see sites such as quality directories rise again. For example, a site dedicated specifically towards programming topics with links to known high quality programming articles.

In a way I cope with that problem by searching for "keyword + name of site that I trust". For example "cross domain javascript fade quirksmode". It works better that way, but it assumes that you already know the names of major "solution providers."

Re:Adieu google by philwelch on Sunday December 06, 2009 @12:05AM (#979190)
That behavior seems popular--most queries, Google Suggest appends "wiki" or "wikipedia" to as a popular search.
Re:Adieu google by NathanKP on Sunday December 06, 2009 @12:12AM (#979198)
That is also probably why Google usually ranks Wikipedia so highly. And that is another solution. Google can make known, trusted websites such as About.com, Wikipedia, Quirksmode, rank highly. They already do that based on domain name age and link backs, and it is part of the reason why it is so hard to rank highly when you start a new site.
Re:Adieu google by ericd on Monday December 07, 2009 @12:56AM (#980807)
Yeah, I think the domain name age is a real problem, since it creates a barrier to entry for new, better stuff, and slows down the evolution of the internet. Not sure how big the weight is, but combined with 10 years of link building, it can be very hard to topple a more established but inferior site.
Re:Adieu google by dtby on Sunday December 06, 2009 @11:56AM (#979768)
Google can make known, trusted websites such as About.com, Wikipedia, Quirksmode, rank highly.

I thought this is what PageRank was supposed to determine algorithmically. I don't trust two out of three of your listed trusted websites, so this would devalue their service to me. Then again, they probably don't care much what I think, since I switched search engines months ago.

Re:Adieu google by pvandehaar on Sunday December 06, 2009 @10:51PM (#980675)
I try to avoid predictions in software further ahead than 30 years. I expect search will be rather unrecognizable by then. Just think back 50 years (PDP-10 and ITS 40 years ago; Apple and Unix at 30; Linux is 15).
Re:Adieu google by zackattack on Sunday December 06, 2009 @12:57AM (#979240)
I know it makes things harder, why can't they implement a suggestion like mine? People stop searching when they find what they're looking for.

Oh, wait. The more searches they do, the more impressions they see. The more impressions they see, the more likely they are to click on an ad. More ad clicks, more money.

Re:Adieu google by cma on Sunday December 06, 2009 @02:05AM (#979286)
They aren't subject to any competition that would counteract the incentive you mentioned?
Re:Adieu google by zackattack on Sunday December 06, 2009 @02:58AM (#979314)
They can't be too greedy, or they'll lose business to competitors. They can't be too selfless, or they won't have the resources to do incredible things.

Hypothesis: Price, efficiency, benefits to the consumer all oscillate over the years, never to converge, as competition naturally enter and exit the field.