Re:Namebench - An Open-source DNS Benchmark Utility
by carbocation on Saturday December 05, 2009 @06:48PM
(#978855)
I ran this against my ISP's DNS as cached by my router, Google's new 8.8.8.8, Level3's 4.2.2.1 and 4.2.2.2, and OpenDNS.
It performed 200 tests in 1 run, using my 100,000 Firefox bookmarks as its data source in 'weighted' mode.
My results were as follows:
"In this test, Your current primary DNS server [my router's cache of Comcast's DNS] is
29% Faster than Google Public DNS".
I am in Boston. In ranked order of performance:
My router's cache of Comcast (48.28ms),
Google's 8.8.8.8 (62.49ms),
OpenDNS (68.14ms),
Level3's 4.2.2.1 (94.37ms),
Level3's 4.2.2.2 (113.51ms)
*Update - I clarified that I tested my router's cache of Comcast's DNS, not Comcast's DNS servers themselves.
Re:Namebench - An Open-source DNS Benchmark Utility
by dfranke on Saturday December 05, 2009 @11:41PM
(#979172)
It shouldn't be surprising. Your ISP's server serves enough customers that most popular sites will be cached most of the time, and you're likely to have a shorter ping time to your ISP's server than to any other.
Re:Namebench - An Open-source DNS Benchmark Utility
by lazyant on Saturday December 05, 2009 @07:43PM
(#978916)
Slightly off-topic but when I first got my MacBook about two years ago the networking was awfully slow compared to my Windows or Linux boxes.
I suspected a DNS problem and after installing a local DNS cache server it improved dramatically, so a local cache-only/forwarder DNS server is another solution for a faster networking experience.
www.google.com. hijacked (google.navigation.opendns.com.) NXDOMAIN Hijacking
It performed 200 tests in 1 run, using my 100,000 Firefox bookmarks as its data source in 'weighted' mode.
My results were as follows: "In this test, Your current primary DNS server [my router's cache of Comcast's DNS] is 29% Faster than Google Public DNS".
I am in Boston. In ranked order of performance: My router's cache of Comcast (48.28ms), Google's 8.8.8.8 (62.49ms), OpenDNS (68.14ms), Level3's 4.2.2.1 (94.37ms), Level3's 4.2.2.2 (113.51ms)
*Update - I clarified that I tested my router's cache of Comcast's DNS, not Comcast's DNS servers themselves.
I was surprised to find my ISP (Cox, San Diego) performed pretty favorably.
Cox (92.73 ms), UltraDNS (100.95 ms), OpenDNS (117.07 ms), Google Public DNS (197.01 ms)
I suspected a DNS problem and after installing a local DNS cache server it improved dramatically, so a local cache-only/forwarder DNS server is another solution for a faster networking experience.