Re:What happens when you stop relying on resumes
by roneesh on Thursday June 25, 2015 @05:24PM
(#9781010)
Shortly after she says she's come to "rely heavily on data", she says "This post, however, is going to be a bit of a departure. Rather than making broad, sweeping conclusions based on a lot of data points, Iām going to narrow in on one story that happened".
I think she did a great job of doing exactly what she set out to do, and since this is just one anecdote, any qualitative or numerical data she presents won't be worth much, all the more reason to omit it and just share the story.
Re:What happens when you stop relying on resumes
by mpenn on Thursday June 25, 2015 @09:57PM
(#9782089)
My bad on that -- I definitely misread the beginning. After rereading, she presents the beginning and end fairly based on an anecdote and not data.
I'd still love to know why the company didn't switch to this full throttle.
This article starts out with an air of science and ends with a completely unproven conclusion.
While I do agree in my gut that resumes are not an amazing filter, she has completely failed to present evidence that her alternative interview process is better.
And in fact, while KeepSafe still has the no resumes option open, they are now accepting resumes again -- I do not great confidence that the alternative system was anything more than a PR move by the company.