Re:Mortgages Are About Math
by mikeash on Thursday June 25, 2015 @02:50PM
(#9780098)
Rising prices seem good superficially because a lot of people own houses and that means everyone is getting rich! The harm on people who don't already own a house is harder to see.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Mortgages Are About Math
by thaumasiotes on Thursday June 25, 2015 @03:00PM
(#9780160)
> Rising prices seem good superficially because a lot of people own houses and that means everyone is getting rich!
But this only helps people who own multiple houses, or don't plan to live in one. If you need a house, the gain you get from selling your existing house after appreciation is necessarily offset by the loss you take buying an appreciated replacement house.
You can't get rich, or benefit at all, from a nominal appreciation in the "price" of something you can't sell.
Re:Mortgages Are About Math
by GauntletWizard on Thursday June 25, 2015 @03:24PM
(#9780321)
When you downsize in retirement, you certainly can. Plenty of people plan to move to florida or other retirement towns when they're older. These places tend to be cheaper to buy houses in; off the beaten path, not near jobs, not good schools, etc - Things retirees don't care about, but youngsters do, that are major effects on housing prices. They can finance this by investing in that they live in in their youth, then selling. If you buy a house at $400,000, and it appreciates 10% over the next 10 years, it is now worth $440,000. You sell it, and move to a house that would have cost you $100,000... but that has appreciated at the same rate, now costing $110,000. You've 'made' $30k, despite appreciation.
Is it just me or does making $30k in 10 years sound absolutely terrible? That's $3k a year ...
There are so many cheaper ways to make an extra $3k per year. You could, for instance, spend 5 hours a week baby sitting for $12/hour.
A reasonable concept is that late in life you will either move to a smaller house or move to a cheaper area or rent thereafter (or get a reverse mortgage or other financial instrument that allows you to lose some equity and still live in "your" house).
It's not as dire as you make out. That said, it's not as awesome as a lot of people seem to think.
In the UK (I have no experience of this type of finance anywhere else), interest rates improve as your loan to value percentage decreases. If the house increases in value by the time you come to re-mortgage, you're likely to get a better deal.
Again, this doesn't help people who are trying to buy for the first time.
Re:Mortgages Are About Math
by steve-howard on Thursday June 25, 2015 @03:06PM
(#9780200)
Sure you can benefit! You can take out a home equity line of credit and cross your fingers that it doesn't come back to bite you.
Re:Mortgages Are About Math
by thaumasiotes on Thursday June 25, 2015 @03:09PM
(#9780218)
An outstanding loan secured by something that you can't lose makes your situation worse, not better. Taking out a line of credit is not fundamentally different from selling the security. :p