> most cities restrict supply of taxis to keep prices high and fix prices as the behest of the taxi industry
Why is it always left out that a limited number of taxis is good for society as well? Taxis operate on public roads, pollute public air, cause traffic congestion the public must deal with, cause car accidents and hit pedestrians. When you're not catching a ride taxis (and Ubers) are a nuisance and society has decided to limit their negative side effects.
[deleted]
Re:How Uber Takes Over a City
by emodendroket on Wednesday June 24, 2015 @02:11PM
(#9773389)
It's not "elegant" because the people harmed in the parent comment's examples are not customers (or at least a large percentage of them are not). There is no way for them to "vote with their wallets."
? The argument is that there are reasons other than inflating prices to regulate the number of taxis on the road. Cars have externalities that society as a whole pays for, it's reasonable to limit those externalities.
But with limiting taxis you increase the amount of cars on the streets, aren't you? People probably won't stop traveling because there are no free taxis. They jump in their own car.
Re:How Uber Takes Over a City
by emodendroket on Wednesday June 24, 2015 @03:27PM
(#9773904)
Do you typically drive around 8 hours a day?
No. I drive twice. And while I do that I'm stuck in the traffic and search for parking lots.
No way everyone driving in their own car is somehow better for the environment than a specialised subset of carholders.
Re:How Uber Takes Over a City
by emodendroket on Wednesday June 24, 2015 @05:05PM
(#9774469)
What I'm saying is that taxis don't drive for an hour or two and then park, they're congesting the streets all day.
Not in the cities where I live. They generally park in specific hubs made for them by city planners in front of strategic places like train stations, hotels etc.
It's Germany though..
Re:How Uber Takes Over a City
by emodendroket on Thursday June 25, 2015 @09:25AM
(#9777658)
Well in many cities there are lots of taxis looking for fares far away from taxi stands. Uber drivers also cannot use them anywhere I know of.
When Seattle built the Link light rail system, it stopped 1 mile shy of the airport because the taxi drivers didn't want the competition. Fortunately public outcry shut that down, but it's pretty rare that the general public gets upset enough about an issue to overcome the power of a specific interest group (yes, this includes Uber as well!)
There's plenty of literature to explain why price fixing and limiting supply/licensure is bad. There's no competition, no incentive to improve or provide a premium service. There's no reason to provide service in far-out areas where it might be hard to find a return fare. There's no reason to provide service in less "desirable" (read: minority) areas.
Of course, there are problems with the Uber model, too: Surge pricing being one of them. Some people think it's gouging, some think it's the right solution to provide supply for excess demand.