If you can't get quickly to an agreement about such a thing, or if the members of the team that didn't get their way actively rebel (or worse sabotage), you are working with a team of divas.
(note: of course developers whinge, as long as you stick with the team decisions once their are made, whinge all you want)
It kinda reminds me of that buzzfeed article "53 Signs Your Boyfriend Is Really Three Children In A Trenchcoat".
Or you're working on such a trivial problem that it should have been given to an individual, not a team.
A well working team will probably do as you say - volunteer an individual to write the rule in an email and follow it from there on.
If you going to introduce changes in a team, like for example introducing Agile (the proper way) or you are starting a new project, you want to quickly gauge the team dynamic, and that's a good exercise.
(make sure to hit F5 a few times)