Where I'm from, recycling started by grabbing simple low-hanging fruit. Newspapers. Aluminium cans. Glass bottles and jars. And it doesn't all go into one "recycling bin", but each thing is separated. Later, that expanded so you can now also recycle metal cans, plastic containers and cardboard. If you want to.
And the default was never landfill, instead all household trash is incinerated for heat and electricity. Sweden even imports trash to burn! And in the case people throw the "wrong" things in general trash, the incinerators can handle it, they're very good at exhaust filtering, and I bet you can even mine the residue for rare materials.
And that all makes sense to me. I can see the economics of it, and I can see the environmental impact of sorting. But the California system of one big "recycling" bin that you're supposed to throw god-knows-what in is completely opaque to me. How does anything useful come out of that? How much labour is needed to sort it at the station?
There are people involved to pull out things that would jam the machines, but generally it's fairly automatable.
Inside New York City’s newest recycling center - Machines use science to separate a stream of waste into valuable raw materials.
http://arstechnica.com/science/2015/01/inside-new-york-citys...
Recycling in the US: An off-again, on-again love affair - It became a booming industry despite facing a series of intractable tradeoffs.
http://arstechnica.com/science/2015/03/recycling-in-the-us-a...
http://www.washingtonpost.com/local/dc-politics/american-rec...
Exhibit 4 has some numbers you'd probably find useful, such as the benefit or recycling in terms of tonnes of Carbon per ton of paper recycled. It looks like about 0.6-0.75 tonnes of Carbon per ton of recycled paper.
(1) Is the material common?
(2) Is recycling it less energy intensive than mining/refining it?
(3) Is it nasty in a landfill? Does it leak, pollute groundwater, etc.?
Aluminum, batteries, electronics, significant amounts of steel, etc. make a lot of sense to recycle. In some cases it's quite profitable without any subsidy. Glass and paper on the other hand, not so much. Paper is an agricultural product, and glass is mostly SiO2 which is an absurdly common material (sand).
As usual the truth here is a lot more complex than the sound bites.