If the money would be divided more fairly the changes between the topteams and backmarkers would be a lot smaller, and teams like Manor might actually find themselves somewhere in the midfield of F1.
The concept this guy drew looks nice, but I don't think it is realistic. He says F1 should have more simple rules so designers have more freedom in designing beautiful cars. Problem is; they don't want to design a beautiful car. The teams are only interested in fast/efficient cars. Give them more freedom and they won't come up with the McLaren in this post but probably with some horrific looking car just because it gains them a few tenths of a second.
Speak for yourself, I'd love to see that. In fact, I'd love if they made all the cars either remote controlled or self driving, and removed most of the safety rules and the restrictions to keep things "competitive". I mean, it could be another sport, with another name. But I'd love to watch that.
Sports are interesting to me because of demonstration of human qualities like hard work, brilliance, endurance and even the mistakes we make. Because they bring out the best in us.
If I have to see how well algorithms work, TopCoder or SPOJ generally does the job, I don't see much fun in two emotionless bots flying on the track without having the faintest clue what the whole thing is all about.
Precisely. Ask people who Ayrton Senna is and they'll probably know he was a F1 driver from Brazil, won championships, died in an accident and was buried as if head of state.
Ask them about the MP4/4 Honda RA168E and even many anoraks will have some trouble telling you what championship year it ran.
My feeling is that F1 has always been about the driver, the engineering and the tactics (including team tactics) and all three should be present. People who want it to be simpler/only about the driver will never be long-term fans anyway.
Finally, remember that (almost) by definition Formula 1 cars must be the quickest racing cars on the planet measured by lap time. The latest rules reduced the aero package and made Formula 1 closer to GP2 and Champ Car.
Montreal circuit, from the Wikipedia page:
Formula 1 2004 1:12.275 Formula 1 2014 1:14.393 Champ Car 2002 1:18.959
Why not use remote-controlled drones, then?
It has to be exciting, but people demand safety. Cars have to be advanced, but differences between them small enough for there to be actual competition. We have lots of technology, but what we like to see is driver skill and not how fast a computer can hurl 600+ kilograms of mass around a track.
As these considerations play out you end up with Formula One. Which is compromise upon compromise. While maintaining some sort of illusion of F1 being the ultimate expression of technology and skill for the uneducated and the ignorant masses.
Don't get me wrong. The drivers and the teams are pretty much the ultimate performers in their respective disciplines. All of the drivers are top athletes that can take a lot more punishment while maintaining higher levels of concentration over longer periods of time than the vast majority of olympians. But they are still part of something that needs to work as a show.
And it just won't pull in any money if you have one or two teams dominating the field completely for year after year.
As any big sport, F1 is closer to pro wrestling than it is to the pure sport we would like to tell ourselves that it is.