News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:To Apple, Love Taylor by threeseed on Sunday June 21, 2015 @09:44AM (#9753396)
> There's the fact that Apple is threatening independent artists with removal from iTunes.

Wrong. Apple has unequivocally stated that this isn't happening.

> iOS users can't download music from the web

Wrong. You can just add it using iTunes.

Re:To Apple, Love Taylor by JohnTHaller on Sunday June 21, 2015 @09:54AM (#9753432)
> Wrong. Apple has unequivocally stated that this isn't happening.

A couple different independent artists online have stated that Apple told them this.

> Wrong. You can just add it using iTunes.

Did you purposely take my quote out of context to make your answer seem correct? I specifically said that iOS users can't download a song from the web or a 3rd party app and add it to their music library like they can on Android. On Android, I can download a song while out on the go from anywhere I want and add it to my music library. Every app can add music, every app can play music. Can you do that on iOS... or do you have to go back to your home computer, add the song to your computer, add it to your iTunes library and then sync it to your iPhone/iPad? The last time I helped a friend do this, this is what we had to do.

Re:To Apple, Love Taylor by threeseed on Sunday June 21, 2015 @10:04AM (#9753472)
> A couple different independent artists online have stated that Apple told them this.

Well I am far more likely to take the measured, legally considered statement from Apple over a single independent artist's Twitter posts. Apple would be in a for a world of hurt if they deliberately mislead people.

> Did you purposely take my quote out of context

No. I am an iOS user and half my music collection is from the web. It is completely legitimate to use iTunes to add it to your collection. Otherwise third party apps exist which allow you to download from the mobile web. I am not saying it isn't as flexible as Android but it is disingenuous to say it isn't possible.

Re:To Apple, Love Taylor by JohnTHaller on Sunday June 21, 2015 @10:13AM (#9753509)
> Well I am far more likely to take the measured, legally considered statement from Apple over a single independent artist's Twitter posts. Apple would be in a for a world of hurt if they deliberately mislead people.

Considering the way Apple lied... ehem... misspoke? misled people?... about ebooks, lying about music isn't that far fetched.

> No. I am an iOS user and half my music collection is from the web. It is completely legitimate to use iTunes to add it to your collection. Otherwise third party apps exist which allow you to download from the mobile web. I am not saying it isn't as flexible as Android but it is disingenuous to say it isn't possible.

So, as I said, it is impossible for an iOS user to just download a song and add it to their music library on the go. It would be technically easy for Apple to enable this, but they purposely disallow this to make it harder for customers to purchase from 3rd parties. The same way they won't let 3rd parties sell music within their apps without paying 30% to Apple (making it financially impossible).

Having to go all the way home, add your music to iTunes, plug your phone into your computer, and then sync to iTunes just to be able to add a single MP3 to your phone's music library may be "legitimate" but it's anything but reasonable. It's in this state solely to make it inconvenient to the user and push them into the open arms of iTunes.

Re:To Apple, Love Taylor by TillE on Sunday June 21, 2015 @12:21PM (#9753933)
They don't even have to be lying. Apple is a huge company, and it's entirely possibly that its representatives may have been making threats that were not, ah, officially authorized.