To more fully explain what I meant by my first response, I was frustrated by his lack of awareness of the ways intersectionality impacts how different people interact with each other online. Codes of Conduct become increasingly important as one recognizes that intersectionalities of oppression can create extremely toxic situations for some minority groups and not others, depending on the context of the group. So, basically what you were saying in your second comment.
Not in the least. This proposal clearly reflects the belief that complaints about discrimination, etc. are "the problem" in communities, not the actual conduct giving rise to the complaints. Thus, it punishes the former while allowing the latter to continue unimpeded.
If this isn't the point, as you say, then what exactly is the point?
Edit: Or maybe the point is this: Whatever the author is trying to discuss in these communities, it is so important that one can't spare the time to address problematic social behavior. If so, I think the author either underestimates the importance of some of the social ills that plague online communities, or his work in these communities is far more urgent than I had realized.
He's free to run a community in that way, but I won't be joining it.