Re:Bitcoin Bucket Shop Kicks Bucket
by tptacek on Friday June 19, 2015 @02:35PM
(#9746739)
A lot of the law around derivatives regulation seems to have the explicit purpose of building a wall between "gambling" and "risk management" (trading, hedging, &c). A regulatory problem with OTC derivatives in the '90s was that they were determined to be gambling devices, not real financial products.
The law is obviously imperfect. But the goal --- don't let us pretend we're financing we're just running games --- seems pretty straightforward.
So to my mind, debating the regs that brought down this exchange takes you in one (or more) of three directions:
1. You can believe we shouldn't regulate gambling at all, because people will find ways to gamble, and many people can gamble responsibly. As Levine points out, we might even benefit from the information generated by the gaming activity.
2. You can believe "main street" investors should have access to private company equity and not just large institutional investors.
3. You can believe we should not have "safety and soundness" as a goal for regulating retail financial transactions, and that the SEC/CFTC/&c should not serve a role for the financial system that is similar to the FDA's role for drugs (lots of people also think that the FDA does more harm than good). That is to say: companies should not have to spend large amounts of money to ensure "truth in labeling" for financial products.
I tend to think you probably have to believe all of these things to think what Sand Hill Exchange was doing should have been lawful. For instance: if you think there's value in generating retail exposure to startup equity, there are obviously saner ways to provide it than relaxing regs on derivatives betting exchanges.
The law is obviously imperfect. But the goal --- don't let us pretend we're financing we're just running games --- seems pretty straightforward.
So to my mind, debating the regs that brought down this exchange takes you in one (or more) of three directions:
1. You can believe we shouldn't regulate gambling at all, because people will find ways to gamble, and many people can gamble responsibly. As Levine points out, we might even benefit from the information generated by the gaming activity.
2. You can believe "main street" investors should have access to private company equity and not just large institutional investors.
3. You can believe we should not have "safety and soundness" as a goal for regulating retail financial transactions, and that the SEC/CFTC/&c should not serve a role for the financial system that is similar to the FDA's role for drugs (lots of people also think that the FDA does more harm than good). That is to say: companies should not have to spend large amounts of money to ensure "truth in labeling" for financial products.
I tend to think you probably have to believe all of these things to think what Sand Hill Exchange was doing should have been lawful. For instance: if you think there's value in generating retail exposure to startup equity, there are obviously saner ways to provide it than relaxing regs on derivatives betting exchanges.