News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IMAX’s absurd attempt to censor Ars by mikeash on Friday June 19, 2015 @10:19AM (#9744907)
Trademark erosion is about using a trademark to describe a similar but differently-branded product. Like if you said, "I saw Star Trek at the IMAX last night" when in fact that theater is not IMAX©®™ƒ branded, but some other big-screen movie theater.

Real-life examples include "give me a kleenex" when you just want any random facial tissue, "give me a coke" when you're just asking for any soft drink (this use is common in some places, while in other places it means only the actual Coca-Cola product), or "I xeroxed this document" when you have no idea of the actual brand of the copier.

Just using the trademark as a comparison doesn't do it, as far as I understand it.

Re:IMAX’s absurd attempt to censor Ars by dpark on Friday June 19, 2015 @12:11PM (#9745705)
> "I saw Star Trek at the IMAX last night"

This is actually still an example of trademark erosion, even if referring to an actual IMAX theater. This is using the brand to refer to the abstract thing. It's not an IMAX. It's an IMAX theater.

For a relevant example, look at Google's guidance to journalists. They say not to write "I googled X", but "I searched for X using Google". Using "google" as the verb, even when literally referring to Google, erodes the brand, because it conflates the brand with the thing.

Re:IMAX’s absurd attempt to censor Ars by chinpokomon on Friday June 19, 2015 @12:51PM (#9746058)
Right, I think that's what was written. The post said that that use of IMAX would be trademark erosion.
Re:IMAX’s absurd attempt to censor Ars by dpark on Friday June 19, 2015 @01:06PM (#9746166)
I'm not sure what you're referring to as "the post". If you're referring to the article, my comment wasn't addressing that at all. My comment was a response only to mikeash's comment. He gave an incomplete description of trademark erosion and I thought it was worth clarifying. Using "IMAX" to refer to a non-IMAX screen would be trademark erosion. Using "IMAX" by itself to refer to an IMAX screen is still trademark erosion. Just as "googling" is an erosion of the Google trademark, even when referring to Google's searching service.

You see the impact of this sort of brand erosion with the iPad. The iPad dominates the tablet space, so the constant references to iPads have started to genericize the term to the point that other tablets are often called iPads (which erodes the brand to a greater extent). Contrarily, BMW for example gets away with this because BMWs do not dominate the market, so there is little danger of "BMW" becoming synonymous with the car. IMAX dominates its market so the brand is quite in danger of becoming a synonym for a giant screen. The smaller erosions are therefore a bigger concern.